In a clash over who should control key properties and potential development in the Hill District, three elected officials have gone to court and asked the state attorney general to intervene over the proposed sale of several buildings by a venerable nonprofit.
The litigation, brought by state Rep. Jake Wheatley, Allegheny County Councilman DeWitt Walton and Pittsburgh Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, all of whom represent the neighborhood, contends that if the Hill House Association plans to sell four of its properties to a UPMC-backed developer, it must do so under the supervision of the attorney general's office.
The nonprofit has been a fixture of the Hill District since 1964, and has long been home to a host of social service and community programs. But in August, the nonprofit's leaders told the community the organization was in dire financial straits and needed to sell off real estate to survive.
Hill House Association leaders plan to sell the Hill House headquarters at 1835 Centre Ave., One Hope Square at 1901-1915 Centre Ave., the Family Dollar Store at 1917 Centre Ave. and the Blakey Program Center at 1908 Wiley Ave. to real estate developer Omicelo LLC.
But the lawsuit, filed earlier this week in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, says Hill House board members have a conflict of interest.
UPMC is an investor in Omicelo, and there are Hill House board members “that have various connections or associations with UPMC. Their participation as members of the Hill House Board of Directors in any contemplated sale of the Hill House Properties would constitute a conflict of interest,” the suit states.
Read More
The litigation says the terms and conditions of the sale “must be presented to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania for consideration, through its Attorney General" and that office can evaluate and object to changes in charitable organizations.
Hill House officials said Friday they've been talking with the attorney general's office, and denied any conflict of interest.
"Whatever issues come up that appear to have a conflict, those individuals recuse themselves," from voting, said Emma Lucas-Darby, Hill House board chair.
"There's been no secrets. Everybody knows the situation we are in. The lawsuit certainly isn't helping us get to a resolution," said Pete Mendes, Hill House's interim executive director.
Ms. Lucas-Darby and Mr. Mendes said their primary concern is continuing to provide services to Hill residents.
"First and foremost, our concern is on the neighborhood and the people that we serve," Mr. Mendes said.
Hill House leaders have said they would retain the Kaufmann Center on Centre Avenue, a senior center on Bedford Avenue, and the Centre-Heldman Plaza, which is home to a Shop'n Save grocery store.
The lawmakers who brought the suit had said publicly in October they wanted to help the organization find short-term financial assistance to delay a property sale.
UPMC officials declined to comment. Joshua Pollard, founder of Strip District-based Omicelo, could not be reached Friday. Neither he nor UPMC are parties to the court action.
When the sale plans were announced at a community meeting in August, many complained they were not informed of the organization’s plans sooner, and expressed fears that UPMC could wield too much influence.
“Our goal is not luxury apartments, it’s to work with the community … I recognize the iconic status [Hill House] has in the neighborhood,” Mr. Pollard said at the time, and reassured community members he wanted to retain social services in the Hill District.
Earlier this year, Omicelo also purchased a group of troubled properties in Homewood, Garfield and Larimer.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.