Rabbi Jeffrey Myers was at CNN’s New York studio earlier this month when a comment he overheard made him consider his own situation.
A student from Stoneman Douglas High School, who was also at the studio, said that he and his classmates were not going to let the mass shooting at their school define them.
Rabbi Myers, of Tree of Life / Or L’Simcha, where a gunman killed 11 worshippers in October, contemplated whether Pittsburgh’s Jewish community would have the same response to tragedy.
“Does that hold true for us as well?” Rabbi Myers said Thursday night. “Is that how we want to be known?”
Rabbi Myers’ reflection came as he took part in a panel on anti-Semitism in America convened by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette at the Heinz Field Hyundai Club. Post-Gazette executive editor David Shribman moderated the panel, which also included Kathleen Blee, a researcher of organized racism and anti-Semitism and dean of Pitt’s Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences; Deborah Lipstadt, a Holocaust historian and professor at Emory University; and Joshua Sayles, director of the Community Relations Council for the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh.
Following up on Rabbi Myers’ rumination about how the mass shooting could come to epitomize the Pittsburgh Jewish community, Ms. Lipstadt offered a hard truth.
Read More
“You’re going to be known for a very long time for what happened at Tree of Life,” she said, adding that what happened here is “seared” into the memory of people all over the world.
The important question, though, is what the community does going forward to address anti-Semitism, she said.
Part of what can be done is recognizing that the hatred of Jews is connected with hatred of other minority groups, Mr. Sayles said. No one, he said, says they hate Jews but like African-Americans or the LGBT community.
One of the “silver linings” that came out of the tragedy was the support that the Jewish community received from the Muslim, Hindu, Bhutanese and other minorities.
“We have an opportunity right now ... as a Jewish community to build these relationships while the iron is hot,” Mr. Sayles said. “It’s our responsibility to take advantage of that.”
Ms. Lipstadt said that it’s also vital to challenge people who hold hateful views against Jews or other people. Rabbi Myers, who took an oath to remove the word “hate” from his vocabulary and now refers to it as the “h-word,” said that was part of the reason he invited President Donald Trump to Pittsburgh after the massacre.
“It was my opportunity to tell the president what was on my mind,” he said.
During the president’s visit, Rabbi Myers said, he told Mr. Trump “Mr. President, we need to tone down the h-speech.”
But that’s not all he told Mr. Trump.
The rabbi also described the horror he experienced the morning of Oct. 27 to the president and first lady.
Melania Trump gasped and covered her mouth. Mr. Trump was speechless, his mouth agape.
“It was the first time I saw his mouth open with nothing coming out,” Rabbi Myers said.
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.