For four hours on Tuesday, Pittsburgh City Council heard passionate testimonies from city residents about UPMC Mercy's planned expansion in Uptown.
In a marathon public hearing in the council's chambers, more than 100 speakers took to the podium to make public comments over a proposed resolution that would approve part of a $2 billion expansion by the hospital.
One by one, opponents of the council resolution — a strong majority of the 116 registered speakers — denounced UPMC's treatment of workers and called on the health enterprise to enter into a community benefits agreement with stakeholders before expanding.
Until then, they said, council should withhold approval of the plan.
"There are a lot of issues that should be addressed before UPMC builds yet another hospital and hires more employees from the Pittsburgh community who will continue to be treated unfairly," said Miranda Bridgwater, a new UPMC employee who graduated from the University of Pittsburgh in 2017.
If approved by council, the resolution would amend UPMC’s institutional master plan — originally approved in 2012 — to allow the health enterprise to modify the use of its property, said Kate Rakus of Pittsburgh’s Department of City Planning.
Read More
By amending its plan, UPMC wants to modify its Uptown campus and replace a previously approved power plant with its new vision and rehabilitation hospital, which the company says is expected to open in 2020 and will offer advanced clinical vision care.
UPMC Mercy Hospital President Michael Grace, in opening remarks at the hearing, said the company had been working with the community since 2017 and has incorporated a variety of suggestions into the amended master plan.
UPMC and Brittany Eckert's story.
But opponents of the resolution contested Mr. Grace's claims, and asked City Council to stand with constituents and demand that the company come to the table with stakeholders to create a community benefits agreement before going forward with the proposed expansion. Speakers, from university faculty members to residents to community leaders, called on UPMC to provide jobs with livable wages.
Darrin Kelly, president of the Allegheny/Fayette Central Labor Council, said organized labor is not against the development, but wants “nothing more” than to partner with UPMC and start fresh without “bad blood.”
UPMC had its supporters at the hearing — nine who registered. They pointed to the hospital expansion as a catalyst for innovation and argued that the hospital had already done its outreach to the community.
Jeanne McNutt, executive director of Uptown Partners of Pittsburgh, said hospital expansion will create a “new benchmark in health and wellness for the region.”
“After decades of disinvestment, deterioration and loss of population, this development for us represents an exciting, catalytic economic development opportunity for Uptown,” Ms. McNutt said.
Opposition to the amendment rallied beforehand with a march Downtown and a press conference with elected leaders and community activists.
At the press conference, Democratic state Rep. Dan Frankel of the 23rd District said taxpayers deserve to be at the table with UPMC because “these doctors and nurses and scientists live among us.”
The council members present at the hearing — President Bruce Kraus, Darlene Harris, Corey O’Connor, Erika Strassburger, Deborah Gross, Anthony Coghill, Ricky Burgess and Daniel Lavelle — were mostly silent during the three-minute testimonies. Theresa Kail-Smith did not attend, but Mr. Kraus said she was monitoring from home due to a family emergency.
It’s up to council to permit UPMC’s expansion plan, said Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner, who added “it should not be made without meaningful, enforceable commitments to good jobs and community benefits that raise us all.”
After the testimonies commenced, Mr. Kraus and Mrs. Harris said they would vote "no" to the resolution without a community benefits agreement.
"I will tell you, I promise you right now: I will be a 'no' vote if UPMC doesn't come to the table and stop it with this nonsense, and do a community benefits plan," Ms. Harris said to applause from the residents remaining in the audience.
Mr. Coghill said that even though his list of concerns has grown, he is "not willing to sell UPMC down the river" yet, and that he wants to see what they bring to the negotiating table first.
Ms. Gross, in her public comments, recapped the arguments from both sides. She had spoken out before the hearing, saying she understands the risks of gentrification and pointing to rising rent costs in Lawrenceville.
Council will vote on the resolution, but not date has been set.
The public hearing, packed wall to wall with attendees, was a success for the groups that had tried for weeks to turn-out union members and hospital workers. Fair Share Action Fund sent out mailers encouraging city residents to show up at the council meeting and “make sure UPMC’s expansion plans benefit us all.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.