On at least six occasions, Pittsburgh zoo staff and volunteers raised concerns about the possibility of a child falling through an open side of the African painted dog exhibit.

“A visitor was seen dangling a child over the exhibit through the opening,” read the minutes of one Safety Committee meeting in August 2006. “Guests are dangling children over the railing at the Wild Dog Exhibit,” read the minutes from a meeting nine months later. “Wild Dogs Exhibit - Children hanging over ledge,” read the minutes from a meeting a month after that.

The subject of their fear was realized on Nov. 4, 2012, when 2-year-old Maddox Derkosh was mauled to death by the dogs after his mother held him up to the opening in the observation deck and he lurched forward and fell, bouncing off a safety net into the exhibit.

A report by the federal government, released this month more than four years after a Freedom of Information Act request by the Post-Gazette, investigates why the concerns of the safety committee — and another zoo council — weren’t acted upon by zoo management.

Advertise with us

As a result of that investigation, the zoo was ultimately fined up to $4,500 for a barrier fence at the outdoor observation deck overlooking the wild dog exhibit that “was not sufficient to prevent a two year old boy from falling into the exhibit causing the African Painted Dogs to attack the boy causing fatal injuries.”

The 41-page “Report of Investigation” released by the U.S. Department of Agriculture is only part of a larger, 522-page report that is still under review.

USDA Report (PDF)

USDA Report (Text)

The zoo said in a statement that “The USDA had conducted 35 inspections at the painted dog exhibit since its opening in 2006. At no time had any concerns or violations regarding this exhibit been identified by the regulatory agency.” The statement also noted that “Due to a confidentiality agreement with the family, the Pittsburgh Zoo cannot legally comment further on this matter.”

Advertise with us

Many of the concerns raised by the safety committee were already made public in the course of the civil lawsuit from Maddox’s parents, Jason and Elizabeth Derkosh, against the zoo, a suit that was settled in 2014 for an amount that remains confidential.

At times, the report paints the safety committee as operating in a sort of absurdist echo chamber. One member of the committee told investigators that “she doesn’t really know where the information goes from the safety committee meetings.”

One keeper who worked at the dog exhibit “stated that he is aware of the fact that safety committee minutes are posted for employees to review, but said he doesn’t read them.”

A woman who was chairperson of the safety committee at the time planned to address the issue of the open side of the wild dog exhibit with PMA, the zoo’s insurance carrier, during a planned walk-through of the zoo facilities. “Ms. [redacted] stated that she contacted Mr. [redacted] at a later date and learned that he handled workers compensation insurance, not facilities insurance issues. For this reason, he did not participate in any walk-throughs for the purposes of evaluating safety at the dog exhibit.”

It’s unclear what happened after that: “She stated she couldn’t recall if she brought up the issue with the dog exhibit at a department head meeting or if she just thought she would handle it through the PMA contact.”

Advertise with us

Another safety committee chair interviewed by investigators said that “she’d like to think that she and zoo personnel had a conversation and dealt with the issue but she just didn’t recall who she met with or how they dealt with it.”

Barbara Baker, president and CEO of the zoo, told investigators that the normal process was that the chair or another member of the safety committee would take the concerns to the appropriate department head. The department head “was empowered to deal with this type of issue without getting prior approval,” she said, and “was authorized to spend up to $1,000 on improvements if he thought they were necessary.”

She said she didn’t usually see safety committee minutes and didn’t recall them being brought to her attention. She also said that she never personally saw anyone stand their child on the rail.

Amos Morris, whose name is redacted in the USDA report but was previously identified in civil litigation as the Curator of Mammals overseeing the dog exhibit, told investigators that “this was the first time that he ever saw these minutes” and that he was not aware of hearing concerns about safety issues with the wild dog exhibit.

Mr. Morris, now deputy director and chief operating officer at the Fresno Chaffee Zoo in Fresno, Calif., said Thursday that he left the Pittsburgh Zoo in 2009, well before the incident. He reiterated that during his tenure, he was never informed of safety committee concerns. “They used to call me Susie Safety because I acted upon any safety concern or animal safety concern,” he said. “I was the safety nut.”

Advertise with us

The zoo in a statement said:

  • Safety is and always will be a priority for the Zoo. We are constantly on alert for safety concerns for our visitors, animals and staff.
  • The Zoo has well-established policies and procedures to constantly evaluate safety and security on our grounds, with state-certified committees. These policies are reviewed and updated every year. Information is communicated to all levels of management.
  • All of the Zoo’s exhibits meet or exceed the highest standards for animal care and visitor safety. After careful inspection, it was determined that the painted dog exhibit continuously exceeded the safety requirements mandated by the USDA and [Association of Zoos & Aquariums].
  • The USDA had conducted 35 inspections at the painted dog exhibit since its opening in 2006. At no time had any concerns or violations regarding this exhibit been identified by the regulatory agency.
  • In 2014, the Zoo opened a new exhibit, highlighting giraffe, zebra and cheetah in the general area where the accident occurred.
  • Due to a confidentiality agreement with the family, the Pittsburgh Zoo cannot legally comment further on this matter.

The report also notes two other instances at the zoo when employees or volunteers raised concerns about the wild dog exhibit outside of the safety committee, though the name of the council in which they were raised is redacted. Minutes from an August 2006 council meeting suggest “that another Plexiglas panel might be needed at the wild dog exhibit.” And minutes from June 2007 suggest “that the open section of the wild dog exhibit is still under discussion and that the installation of bars have been considered.”

The zoo’s volunteer coordinator told investigators that that council was not the proper place to raise those concerns, and that they should be handled by the safety committee.

The report also includes interviews with Pittsburgh Police officers who responded to the scene, including one who was assigned to spend time with Ms. Derkosh. The report describes her screaming at the scene: “Why wasn’t there Plexiglas? I thought there was Plexiglas.”

The family attorney for the Derkoshes, Robert Mongeluzzi, did not return a call for comment. A charity established by the family, Trucks for Maddox, operates in his memory, donating toy construction vehicles to children in need.

Advertise with us

The zoo closed the wild dog exhibit after Maddox’s death and also made safety improvements to the tiger exhibit, which had also been referenced in safety committee meetings.

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.