A top Allegheny County prosecutor sided Tuesday with the defense in seeking to remove the presiding judge in a rape case, and he argued that her behavior might warrant a referral to the state board that investigates judicial misconduct.

Deputy District Attorney Michael Streily made his comments before a three-judge Superior Court panel meeting in Pittsburgh to hear arguments about whether Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel should recuse herself from the sentencing of a man convicted in 2014 of rape and years-long abuse of a girl.

Judge McDaniel has already been a target of scrutiny by the Superior Court, which has questioned whether she has issued unduly harsh sentences to sex offenders.

Mr. Streily's statements were striking in their bluntness, for the willingness of the DA's office to publicly criticize a sitting judge for her demeanor, and for openly raising the question of whether the Judicial Conduct Board should be alerted.

Advertise with us

"If this court has found that Judge McDaniel has reached the point where it believes she has bias toward sex offenders, it's not only just a remand, the court has to refer her to the proper authority,” Mr. Streily told the panel. "We are at the point where you have to decide: Has this judge lost her ability to sentence sex offenders?”

Mr. Streily also said that animosity between Judge McDaniel and the county public defender's office over sentencing sex offenders has risen "to a level of uncivilized behavior."

During the past 16 months, Superior Court twice has suggested that Judge McDaniel might be showing a pattern of sentencing sex offenders to overly lengthy prison terms. In both cases, the court ordered her to resentence defendants. And in both, she gave the defendants the same penalty she had the first time around.

In the case argued Tuesday, the underlying legal question was whether Judge McDaniel’s original sentence for Anthony McCauley of 20 to 40 years in prison was mandatory or discretionary. The case was appealed and sent back to Judge McDaniel to clarify.

While Judge McDaniel changed the penalty only slightly to 20 years less two days to 40 years less four days, her actions triggered a war of words between her and the public defender's office.

Advertise with us

Both the defense and prosecution agree that however slight the modification, what occurred was a resentencing, and that meant McCauley was entitled to due process, including a right to speak on his own behalf. Both sides agreed that McCauley was not granted due process during the brief hearing when his sentence was changed

In a June opinion, Judge McDaniel wrote that she complied with the Superior Court’s order to clarify her sentence by explaining that the original penalty was not mandatory. She also noted that at his original sentencing hearing, McCauley was afforded all of his due-process rights.

“Although it belies all rational thought, if the defendant is actually complaining that this court reduced his sentence by a few days, this court would be happy to re-impose sentence to add those additional days back in,” she wrote. “However, it seems vastly more likely that defense counsel, in a fit of pique, has simply made it her mission to disagree with every aspect of this court's decision. Not only is this a drain on valuable appellate court resources, but because it causes both appellate counsel's and her office's credibility to become strained, it is also harmful to other criminal defendants who may actually have meritorious claims.”

Judge McDaniel, who declined to comment for this story, went on to write that attorneys in the public defender’s office “have made it their mission in recent times to attack every sentence this court has imposed, raising obviously meritless claims of error for the sole purpose of averring errors against this court...”

McCauley’s attorney, Assistant Public Defender Stephanie Noel, had asked Judge McDaniel to recuse herself from his case, alleging potential bias based on the earlier Superior Court opinions.

Advertise with us

"Judge McDaniel has displayed animosity toward me and my office which warrants recusal on this case," Ms. Noel said. "If you think that amounts to actual bias, you have the right to do that now."

In her opinion on that issue, Judge McDaniel wrote that the defense attorney's reliance on those cases was "highly improper and demonstrative of her agenda."

Judge McDaniel accused Ms. Noel and the attorney in the earlier cases, Victoria Vidt, of demonstrating "a coordinated effort to attack every sentence imposed by this court, whether or not the claim has merit."

Mr. Streily told the court that the tone Judge McDaniel used in her opinion was “very offensive” — particularly for calling out the individual attorneys by name — and said it demonstrates her feelings about the public defender’s office. On the contrary, his brief said, McCauley's attorneys kept a civil tone in all their pleadings. He suggested the Judge McDaniel reserve her vitriol for the Superior Court.

Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning said Tuesday that no one had raised any issues with him.

Advertise with us

"I'd be happy to attempt to ameliorate any situations," he said. "Judge McDaniel is a very fine judge who has handled all of her cases fairly and without prejudice. A legitimate disagreement between the court and counsel about the law should not be the subject of judicial discipline."

Arthur Hellman, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh who specializes in judicial ethics, said it's unusual for attorneys to be so forthright when talking about an individual judge at oral argument.

"The fact that the prosecutor agrees that the defendant did not get due process is something that will carry heavy weight with the Superior Court," Mr. Hellman said.

While he would not call the dispute between Judge McDaniel and the public defender's office "uncivilized behavior," Mr. Hellman did say it was inappropriate.

There is a case in the federal court system, he said, that establishes that a judge's refusal to follow the mandates of a higher court can be misconduct.

Advertise with us

"Misconduct is separate from the issue of recusal," he said. "It is very rare for courts to find actual bias, but this may be one of those instances. Even if the Superior Court is reluctant to level such a serious accusation against Judge McDaniel, it could still take her off the case based on the appearance of bias."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.