Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel has once again set herself up for a potential clash with the state Superior Court.

Ordered to resentence a sex offender after the appellate panel found she was overly harsh the first time, Judge McDaniel imposed the exact same punishment on the defendant on Thursday.

It was the second time since June that the judge basically thumbed her nose at the Superior Court and meted out the same penalty for which the cases had originally been returned to her.

In the case on Thursday, A.S., now 22, pleaded guilty to four counts of indecent assault of a child less than 13, two counts of unlawful contact with a minor, two counts of endangering the welfare of children, two counts of corruption of minors, sexual assault, indecent assault and incest.

Advertise with us

The victims in the case were his siblings, which is why he is identified in the opinion only by his initials.

At the original sentencing on June 24, 2015, Judge McDaniel ordered A.S. to serve 7½ to 15 years in prison.

The standard, recommended guideline range for all of the counts together was 3 years 3 months up to 6½ years.

Defense counsel for A.S. challenged his sentence, saying Judge McDaniel relied on information not present in the case to support the penalty she handed down.

The state Superior Court, in a 36-page opinion issued in January, ordered that A. S. be resentenced.

Advertise with us

President Judge Emeritus John Bender wrote that the penalties A.S. received for sexual and indecent assault "were both clearly unreasonable."

The cases, he said, called out for a "mitigated or, at least, a standard range sentence."

Included in the mitigation presented by defense attorney Jamie Schuman on Thursday, A.S. sought psychological treatment prior to his arrest; he has participated in a number of programs for sexual offenders and mental health treatment in prison; he has strong familial support; and the victims have forgiven him.

Two letters from the victims were included in the defense sentencing memorandum. Judge McDaniel said that she read them, but that she would have given them more credence had there been an independent evaluation completed.

The mother of A.S. testified that the entire family has forgiven her son.

Advertise with us

“He wishes he could go back and change things,” she said. “We do not condone his actions. We forgave [him] a long time ago. We just want to help him get back into society.”

A.S. asked the court to order him to serve a standard-range sentence so he could complete the state corrections system sex offender program -— which is not yet available to him because of the length of his prison term.

In a statement he read from the witness stand, A.S. told Judge McDaniel he has been assaulted in prison more than once, and that his guilt is unending. He acknowledged the pain he caused his family and the trust issues he caused his siblings, likely for the rest of their lives.

But he went on, “Over the years, I’ve changed. I’m so glad for the support I’ve had.”

Judge McDaniel acknowledged the mitigating factors in the case, and then recounted what she considered to be aggravating ones -— that a doctor found that A.S. had a moderate-to-high risk to re-offend; that he violated a position of trust with the victims; that he had only sporadic employment and had “accomplished very little in his life.”

Advertise with us

A.S. was 19 at the time of his arrest. He has been incarcerated for more than two years.

“It’s my impression of the sentencing law that the court may impose any of these sentences as long as they are individualized for the defendant,” Judge McDaniel said.

The maximum sentence, she noted, could have been 90 years in prison.

Arthur Hellman, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh who specializes in judicial ethics, said sentencing can be difficult because the punishment must fit both the crime and the criminal. Although judges have discretion, he said, there are sentencing guidelines to protect against wide disparity among defendants.

“Here we seem to have a judge who’s going her own way in this class of cases, and they’re not supposed to do that,” Mr. Hellman said. “The appellate court was giving a pretty clear signal they thought the sentence should be lowered.”

Advertise with us

Prior to announcing the penalty for A.S., Judge McDaniel gave a lengthy statement from the bench, criticizing the Allegheny County Public Defender’s office for presenting what she considered to be inaccurate information to the appellate court of a “blanket policy of going above the guidelines.”.

She recounted what she said was her own statistical analysis of her caseload between 2012 and 2016.

Judge McDaniel said that during those years, 226 of her cases were appealed to the Superior Court and of those, 11 were remanded based on the merits.

“Statistically, this court’s sentencing pattern is comparable to other judges in this division,” she said. “This court does not, in fact, sentence above guidelines in every case, despite defense counsel’s assertions.”

“May I briefly respond, your honor?” Ms. Schuman asked.

Advertise with us

“I’m sorry, no,” the judge answered.

The statistics Judge McDaniel cited were the same ones -— delivered in the same manner -— that she provided at another sex offender resentencing hearing in June.

In that case, it was the third time Judge McDaniel sentenced Gabino Bernal, who was convicted of sexually assaulting an 8-year-old girl.

The same Superior Court panel that remanded the case against A.S. and expressed concern about a possible pattern by Judge McDaniel also remanded that of Bernal, who was first ordered to serve nine to 18 years in prison. That penalty was reduced after the Superior Court found that one count had been graded incorrectly.

At Bernal's first resentencing in 2015, Judge McDaniel ordered him to serve six to 17 years, stacking each count to run consecutively. The Superior Court again remanded, writing in its opinion that the judge failed to explain why she departed from the recommended guidelines range, which on the aggravated end called for three years in prison.

Advertise with us

She resentenced Bernal again in June, and again gave him six to 17 years in prison. Bernal has again appealed to Superior Court.

“It’s not healthy when a judge personalizes her disagreements with the appellate court and counsel in that way,” Mr. Hellman said.

He believes that the case of A.S. ought to be assigned to a different judge -— something the Superior Court had suggested in a footnote, recommending he file a motion for Judge McDaniel to recuse.

The defense attorney filed that motion, and the judge denied it.

John Burkoff, who recently retired from Pitt's law school, said there is every chance that Judge McDaniel's sentence of A.S. was lawful if she supported it by outlining her reasoning.

Advertise with us

"That said, it can be argued that by failing to consider and to respond adequately to the Superior Court's basic unhappiness with her sentencing practices in these types of cases, the judge once again erred," Mr. Burkoff said. "So which is it: proper or improper? Sadly, it seems likely that we'll have to wait for the Superior Court to rule once again in order to find out."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.