Editor’s note: This story has been updated to correct an earlier version, which had a photo of a person not mentioned in or connected to the article.

A Pittsburgh police officer is accused of falsifying a report and hindering an investigation in an attempt to protect another officer who allegedly pointed a gun at a motorist during a road rage incident in May, according to court records.

Officer Kaelen T. O’Connor, 31, of Banksville, is charged with obstructing the administration of law, official oppression, hindering apprehension or prosecution and unsworn falsification to authorities, according to a criminal complaint filed April 6. All four charges are misdemeanors.

Officer O’Connor has been suspended without pay, a police spokesman said Friday.

Advertise with us

Police launched an immediate investigation when they became aware of “possible unethical and criminal conduct by a member of Pittsburgh police” Chief Scott Schubert said.

“The Pittsburgh police will not tolerate this behavior and did everything possible to hold those involved accountable for their actions,” Chief Schubert said.

The incident involved at least eight officers, according to the complaint, and began May 3, when a driver named Jesse Smith called 911 to report a road rage incident at the intersection of Chartiers Avenue and Straka Street in Sheraden.

Mr. Smith, whose age and neighborhood were not listed in court records, told authorities that he was driving his sport-utility vehicle when a black Mercedes pulled alongside him. The driver of the Mercedes, later identified as Officer Robert Kramer, rolled down his window and the two began to argue about speed and reckless driving, according to court records.

Next thing he knew, Mr. Smith said, he was “looking down the barrel of a silver revolver with a short barrel, with bullets in the chambers,” according to the criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

Mr. Smith then told Officer Kramer to get out of his car, at which point Officer Kramer sped away, according to the criminal complaint. Officer Kramer later told investigators that he’d been holding a silver cell phone, not a gun.

Mr. Smith called 911 at 3:36 p.m.

For the next 31 minutes, according to the complaint, a flurry of initial checks and phone calls took place. Officers O’Connor and Troy Signorella, who both worked in Zone 6, responded to the scene. Mr. Smith gave the officers a description of the suspect and a partial license plate.

3:46 p.m.: Officer O’Connor used his in-car computer to determine the complete license plate and look up the registered owner. He logged in using his former partner’s username and password, according to the complaint.

That check revealed Officer Kramer as the owner of the Mercedes and listed his address in the 900 block of Climax Street, in police Zone 3. Officer Signorella asked Zone 3 officers to go to the address — but, after eight phone calls between four officers, they never followed through, according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

3:50 p.m.: Officer Signorella called Officer Raymond Toomey — who days later was involved in a controversial, violent arrest on the South Side and has since resigned from the force.

3:53 p.m.: Officer Toomey called Officer Kramer — the suspect in the case — and the call lasted two seconds. Simultaneously Officer O’Connor called Officer Signorella.

3:54 p.m.: Officer Kramer returned Officer Toomey’s call and they spoke for nearly two minutes.

3:56 p.m.:  Officer Toomey called Officer Signorella twice, then Officer Signorella asked dispatch to disregard sending officers to the address on Climax Street. But five officers had already responded. Officers Pamela DeGuffroy, Zachary Webb, Gary Lis and Officer Toomey’s partner, Richard Dilimone, arrived at the home but were turned away by Officer Toomey, according to the complaint.

He told the officers that the person who lived at the address was a police officer and they could leave, according to the criminal complaint. All the officers left.

Advertise with us

3:58 p.m.: Officer Signorella called Officer O’Connor.

4:05 p.m.: Officer O’Connor called Officer Kramer.

4:07: p.m. Officers end communications on the case, according to the complaint.

The next day, Officer O’Connor submitted an official report about the incident, according to the complaint.

The report made no mention of Officer Kramer, his address or his complete license plate, according to the complaint. The report also did not include the fact that officers had been sent to the home on Climax Street. The suspect in the case is listed as “unknown,” according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

The investigation of the road rage incident ended until Mr. Smith repeatedly called police to ask about it, according to the complaint. On June 6, Zone 6 Detective Dawn Mercurio pulled up the report and began her own investigation.

She called Officer Kramer, who admitted he was in the car but denied pointing a gun, instead saying he was holding a cell phone. Officer Kramer also initially denied owning a silver revolver, until subsequent investigation showed he purchased a Smith & Wesson revolver in 2013 and used it for police firearm training that same year, according to court records.

Officer Kramer’s attorney, Blaine Jones, said Friday his client maintains he is innocent in the road rage incident and is preparing for trial.

“We are anticipating a not-guilty verdict when the evidence comes out,” Mr. Jones said.

After Detective Mercurio talked with Officer Kramer, the investigation was “eventually” referred to the city’s Office of Professional Standards, which investigates police misconduct, according to the complaint. Officer Kramer was charged with simple assault on Aug. 8 and the charges were later held for court. He was fired Oct. 6.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kramer, Mr. Toomey and Officer O’Connor were classmates in the police academy and were hired in April 2013, according to city records.

Officer Signorella was hired in 1995. He remains on the force and is assigned to the warrant office, according to city records.

Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board, said she opened an inquiry into the case Friday because of many unanswered questions — including why Officer Signorella is not facing criminal charges.

“Why, with the phone calls that were exchanged and all the obvious effort to obstruct any investigation into Kramer’s behavior, why has one of those individuals not been charged?” she said. “What exonerated that person’s conduct, in the same incident for the same reasons?”

Chief Schubert said in a statement he is prohibited from discussing disciplinary issues concerning members of the Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge No. 1.

Advertise with us

“Based on the ongoing criminal investigation, we have no reason to believe any other active member of the PBP was involved in this criminal misconduct,” he said.

Officer O’Connor and Mr. Toomey could not be reached for comment Friday. Officer Signorella declined to comment.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.