Even as he stood Monday to be sentenced on 19 counts related to the theft of more than $230,000 from three different organizations, the former president of the Taylor Allderdice High School Alumni Association proclaimed his innocence.
And when Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kevin G. Sasinoski ordered Jeffrey Rosenthal to serve 21 years of probation and pay restitution, Mr. Rosenthal continued his refrain, blaming his conviction on his former attorney’s failure to present essential evidence at trial last fall.
That attorney, Kevin Abramovitz, is facing criminal charges that he helped to cover up the drug overdose death of a friend and was using illegal substances.
Mr. Rosenthal and his new attorney, Chris Rand Eyster, believe that the circumstances surrounding Mr. Abramovitz’s actions entitle him to a new trial.
Rosenthal addresses the media
"The point was, he was not represented effectively," Mr. Eyster said.
But Judge Sasinoski repeatedly cut off Mr. Eyster from presenting any of that information. Instead, at Mr. Rosenthal's sentencing hearing, each time the attorney got close to the issue of Mr. Abramovitz's pending criminal case, the judge stopped him.
"That's not an issue for today. That's for down the road," the judge said. "This is not a trial of Mr. Abramovitz."
Mr. Rosenthal, 64, did not testify at his trial, Mr. Eyster said, and even though Mr. Abramovitz told him they would call their own forensic accounting expert to counter the prosecution's evidence, they never did.
Mr. Abramovitz told the jury that there was no crime at all — just a lack of record-keeping and bookkeeping. Witnesses Monday said Mr. Rosenthal would spend his own money and then reimburse himself.
"We're not here concerning the trial tactics or strategy," Judge Sasinoski said during the sentencing hearing.
Instead, the judge forced the defense to address what punishment Mr. Rosenthal must serve.
A jury found the Squirrel Hill man guilty in October of forgery, receiving stolen property, theft by deception and misapplication of property from 2009 through 2015 from the Taylor Allderdice High School Alumni Association, from the 14th Ward Baseball Association and from the junior varsity baseball group.
Jeff Shook, the vice president of the 14th Ward baseball group, said in a victim-impact statement that Mr. Rosenthal's actions have caused distrust in the community, both among kids playing baseball and among sponsors.
"The money that he took could have funded a variety of expenditures that would make the league stronger and the experience for kids better,” Mr. Shook wrote. “While Jeff was president of the league we were consistently informed that money was not available for things like new equipment, extra baseballs, coaching supplies, field maintenance, or field upgrades.”
But Mr. Eyster called several witnesses Monday who testified about his client’s character relative to his contributions to the baseball organization. Their testimony supplemented a number of letters the court received.
Ralph Smith, who met Mr. Rosenthal about 20 years ago, said he was a kind and generous man who inspired him in coaching. Mr. Smith told the court he often saw Mr. Rosenthal use his own money to pay for 14th Ward Baseball expenditures, and that he often paid the registration fees for kids who couldn’t.
“His character was beyond reproach,” Mr. Smith said. “This man dedicated his life to this program, and it’s insulting to be devalued like this.”
Both Mr. Rosenthal and his wife of 41 years, Lynn, testified that the allegations against him have sullied decades of his volunteerism — including his work at the fields from 8 a.m. to sundown on weekends.
“We’ve gone from community leaders and pillars of the community to pariahs,” Mr. Rosenthal said. “It’s been devastating.”
“Were you involved with these associations to steal money from them?” Mr. Eyster asked.
“Absolutely not, no way,” Mr. Rosenthal answered.
Mr. Eyster said he plans to challenge the restitution amount proposed by the prosecution, and the judge said he would allow the parties to hold a hearing on that issue as well as on others raised relative to Mr. Abramovitz.
None of that, however, will occur before Mr. Abramovitz’s criminal case concludes. His trial is scheduled for May before Judge Jeffrey A. Manning.
In the meantime, Mr. Abramovitz continues to practice law. Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and law professor, said that since the state Disciplinary Board, which regulates attorney conduct, has not already filed an emergency petition to suspend Mr. Abramovitz, it is not likely to do so.
“The charges are serious here. This is not like a DUI,” he said. “But the thing is, they haven’t done it yet. It might be inferred it is not sufficiently egregious to do that yet.”
Under the Rules of Professional Conduct, Mr. Antkowiak said, once an attorney is convicted of a crime, that becomes grounds for disciplinary action. However, it is only when the illegal conduct alleged is “egregious,” that a suspension would be sought while the case is pending.
For Mr. Eyster to prove that Mr. Rosenthal got ineffective assistance of counsel from Mr. Abramovitz at trial, he would have to show not only that errors were made but that they were “sufficiently prejudicial to warrant a new trial.
“It’s not an easy task,” Mr. Antkowiak said.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter:@PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.