A week after a school shooting in Parkland, Fla., left 17 dead, the four candidates running in the special election for City Council District 8 wrestled with how to prevent such tragedies from happening here.
“I want the guns gone now, all of them,” restaurant owner Sonja Finn told a crowd of more than 150 at a candidates’ debate at the Squirrel Hill Jewish Community Center on Thursday night.
“The city can … ban guns in the city,” said Rennick Remley, a Republican who was recently endorsed by the Fraternal Order of Police. He didn’t specifically support such a move, explaining, “It’s certainly something we could do.”
Gun-rights groups would likely sue over such a ban, or any other ordinance that might go beyond state law -- and they have won such cases in the past. But Ms. Finn indicated a willingness to go to court over measures such as an ordinance requiring gun owners to report lost or stolen firearms. “Mayor [Bill] Peduto ran on the lost-and-stolen bill and then didn’t follow through,” she said, citing a 2013 campaign promise. “Let’s push that.”
“It’s easy to say, in theory, let’s bring on the lawsuit,” countered Erika Strassburger, who served as chief of staff for the district’s previous councilman, Dan Gilman. But “It’s a different conversation once you’re there in office,” with city attorneys warning that a court loss could cost millions of dollars.
She recommended a more cautious approach, advocating for a lost-and-stolen law on the state level while organizing efforts such as gun buybacks locally.
Read More
Businessman and LGBT advocate Martin Healey, who is running as an independent, took a similar tack, noting that a citywide ban wouldn’t counter the fact that “someone can bring a gun in from an outlying county. ... We have to work with our state Legislature.”
The gun issue reflected a broader dynamic in the debate, in which the two male candidates struck middling courses as differences between the female candidates became clear.
District 8 includes Shadyside and portions of Oakland, Point Breeze and Squirrel Hill. Its seat on council has been vacant since Mr. Gilman became Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff in January.
Both women could argue a claim to being the frontrunner. Ms. Finn is the Democratic nominee, but Ms. Strassburger, running as an independent after losing the Democratic nomination, has a sizable financial advantage and the backing of leaders including Mr. Peduto and Mr. Gilman.
On issues including transit and development priorities, Ms. Finn was often a more strident critic of the status quo. Ms. Strassburger, whose first-hand knowledge of council has been on display in such forums, offered more nuanced critiques of city policy.
The two also offered different takes on a potential strike by city school teachers, with Ms. Strassburger worrying a “strike isn’t in the best interests of our students,” and Ms. Finn saying, “I support [teachers’] efforts to get what they need.”
The special election will be held March 6, and the candidates have been cordial so far. Ms. Finn told the audience that while the choice might not be easy, “That’s exciting that we have an election where [it’s] a hard decision.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.