A missing camera roiled Jennifer Tracy’s life for nine years.
The 45-year-old Carrick woman was convicted of stealing a city-owned camera from the rental property of an off-duty Pittsburgh police detective in 2008, though she maintained — then and now — that she was innocent and the detective lied about the theft.
Now, that homicide detective, Margaret ‘Peg’ Sherwood, 51, of Brookline, is charged with lying and falsifying reports in three cases — and Tracy hopes the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s office, which filed the charges against Ms. Sherwood in January, will also review her case.
“It was all lies,” Tracy said this week. “But who is the judge going to believe — me, a convicted felon, or a supposedly honest police officer?”
The incident began in July 2008, when Tracy stopped by a three-bedroom house on Stratmore Street in Crafton Heights to inquire about renting it from Ms. Sherwood, who owned the property.
After looking at the house on July 18, Tracy asked Ms. Sherwood if she could return the next day with her three young children, and Ms. Sherwood told her she was welcome to swing by, according to a transcript of Tracy’s non-jury trial in Feb. 2010.
Read More
The house had been left in a state of disarray by the past renters, Tracy said, and Ms. Sherwood said she’d be making repairs and doing renovations at the house throughout the next day.
Tracy returned to the house with her children on July 19. She parked out front and two of her children, excited, ran up the steps and into the house. Tracy pointed out a couple of the home’s outdoor features to her older son, and then followed her younger children inside. The home’s front door was unlocked.
“I didn’t think twice about it, I figured Peggy let [the kids] in,” Tracy said. “So I did the same thing.”
Inside, tools were strewn about the home, Tracy said, and it looked like someone had been working. But no one was home.
Tracy said she poked around a bit, called out Ms. Sherwood’s name, and showed her kids a couple of rooms before she left. On her way out, she called Ms. Sherwood and left a 42-second voicemail, in which she told Ms. Sherwood she was at the house, according to the transcript. Tracy testified she also offered to lock the front door in the voicemail. Ms. Sherwood testified Tracy never said she went inside the house.
Tracy then took her kids to see another rental property, she said. A couple of hours later, Ms. Sherwood called.
“She asked if I had been in her property and I said, ‘Yes,’” Tracy said. “And then she said, ‘I need that camera back.’”
Ms. Sherwood accused Tracy of stealing a city-owned camera and lens worth $1,500 from inside the home. Ms. Sherwood left the camera in a bag on a table, she later testified in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, and left the house unlocked for about 45 minutes while she and her husband picked up supplies from a hardware store.
It’s not clear why Ms. Sherwood had a city-owned camera at her personal rental property while she was not on-duty. Ms. Sherwood retired from Pittsburgh police in 2017.
When Ms. Sherwood accused Tracy of stealing the camera, Tracy returned to Ms. Sherwood’s property and denied the theft. When Ms. Sherwood told Tracy she was a Pittsburgh police detective, Tracy allowed Ms. Sherwood to take down her name and address and offered to let her question her children, she said.
Ms. Sherwood then told Tracy she had an hour to return the camera or she’d call the police, Tracy said. Unsure of what to do, Tracy and a friend who gave her a ride sat in a car outside Ms. Sherwood’s house for a half-hour, waiting for police, but they never showed up, according to court records.
Ms. Sherwood reported the theft to Detective Eric V. Morton on July 24, court records show. He charged Tracy with defiant trespass and theft on Aug. 4. She faced a maximum five years in prison. Investigators never found the camera.
Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning found Tracy guilty of theft and not guilty of trespassing after a brief non-jury trial in February 2010. During the trial, Ms. Sherwood testified that she became suspicious of Tracy when she called Tracy after the camera went missing.
Ms. Sherwood testified that Tracy brought up the camera before Ms. Sherwood mentioned it.
“She said, ‘I can’t believe you left your door unlocked with your camera on the table,’” Ms. Sherwood testified, according to a trial transcript. Tracy said she only discussed the camera after Ms. Sherwood accused her of stealing it.
Both women agreed that there were a couple of yard workers at the home that afternoon. Ms. Sherwood testified that the men gave her their names and addresses, and said her husband checked their pickup truck for the camera but didn’t see it. They did not testify at trial, and neither did Detective Morton. Tracy’s son did testify.
Judge Manning sentenced Tracy to two years of probation and $1,500 in restitution. Tracy failed to pay the restitution and as a result remained on probation for years, until she borrowed money from a relative to pay the remaining $900 balance last August.
For her, the misdemeanor conviction was devastating. She’d been in trouble with the law when she was younger — a felony drug manufacturing conviction in 1993 at age 20, a misdemeanor conviction in 1991 and two more in 1995. But she cleaned up her act and wasn’t charged with a crime in the 13 years before the camera theft, court records show.
“I was just at a point in my life when I felt like I could get a good job because my felonies were more than 10 years in the past, and then this happened,” she said.
She was embarrassed by the conviction and furious with Ms. Sherwood, but she did not file an appeal. She was short on money — her attorney, Sumner Parker, charged her about $2,600, some of which she never paid — and she was spooked by an encounter with law enforcement a few days after she was convicted. Mr. Parker could not be reached for comment.
The day of her trial, Feb. 2, 2010, a death threat against Judge Manning was spray-painted on the courthouse. Within a week of her conviction, Allegheny County Sheriff’s detectives showed up at her house and said they needed to talk to her 13-year-old son. They’d gotten an anonymous tip that he was the spray-painting culprit, they told her.
“My heart sank,” she said. “I was like first me, and now my son. It scared the crap out of me. Like I can’t win. It was them against me. And for years it drove me crazy.”
She thinks Ms. Sherwood called in the tip.
Sheriff William Mullen said he spoke with his investigators Thursday and they said that Ms. Sherwood did not provide the tip about Tracy’s son; the sheriff’s department has no record of an interview with the youth. A 39-year-old man, Paul Rodriquez Sirmons, was later convicted of making the threat.
After news broke this month that Ms. Sherwood was charged with lying in cases she’d investigated, Tracy walked into the Attorney General’s office and asked for help, she said.
A spokesman for the office, Joe Grace, said Thursday he could neither confirm nor deny whether the office was looking into Tracy’s case.
Rebecca Spangler, Allegheny County’s first assistant district attorney and chief of staff, said Thursday that if Tracy files a petition seeking review of her case based on the pending charges against Ms. Sherwood, her office would do a full review like any other.
She said she had not reviewed Tracy's case but that it's not unusual for her office to prosecute a crime based on one person's word.
"That's 90 percent of our cases," Ms. Spangler said. "When someone comes in and reports a crime, the presumption is they have been the victim of a crime — regardless of what their status is. We have to treat everyone the same."
In a case like Tracy's, a police officer would have written the arrest affidavit, and no one from the district attorney's office would have seen it until the case went to a preliminary hearing, she said.
Pittsburgh police spokeswoman Alicia George said it would be “inappropriate” for the police bureau to comment on the matter, given the criminal charges against Ms. Sherwood.
Ms. George would not say whether Ms. Sherwood reported the city camera as stolen to her superiors at the time, whether Ms. Sherwood paid for the camera or whether homicide detectives are allowed to use city-owned cameras for personal tasks.
Current police policy states that employees must pay out of pocket to replace all bureau-issued items that are lost or stolen “in circumstances other than official police action.”
Ms. Sherwood could not be reached for comment and her attorney, Patrick Thomassey, said he could not address the specifics of Tracy's case.
That Tracy was charged with the crime and convicted, he said, was not surprising.
"That is not at all unusual. Domestic violence cases are often he said, she said with no other evidence. That's why the DA's office should review cases beforehand,” he said. "Judges have to make credibility decisions every day."
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @ShellyBradbury. Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.