A veteran Pittsburgh homicide detective who has been on paid administrative leave since April after questions arose over her handling of a photo array presented her side of the story Tuesday to Acting Public Safety Director Mike Huss and other city officials.
The city is expected to make a decision about Detective Margaret “Peg” Sherwood within 10 days, according to Bryan Campbell, the union attorney who represented her at the appeal hearing.
In September, police Chief Cameron McLay gave Detective Sherwood a five-day suspension pending termination, Mr. Campbell said. Detective Sherwood appealed.
The incident that resulted in Detective Sherwood first being moved to the warrant office and then put on leave occurred in January, Mr. Campbell said. Detective Sherwood was working on a homicide case that was before a grand jury. She asked a colleague, Detective Ed Fallert, to assemble a photo array, which Detective Sherwood then presented to a witness, Mr. Campbell said. When writing up the report, however, Detective Sherwood mistakenly put Detective Fallert’s name on the accompanying paperwork, according to the attorney.
Mr. Campbell said Detective Fallert noticed the error when they were at the grand jury together. Detective Fallert testified on his colleague’s behalf at Tuesday’s closed-door appeal hearing, according to Mr. Campbell.
“The question I had is, what does she gain by doing that? Sooner or later it’s going to come out that he didn’t show [the array]. Why would she put his name in there? It’s so stupid to assume she did it intentionally,” Mr. Campbell said. “It’s a mistake.”
Read More
Pittsburgh police policy generally requires detectives to administer “blind” photo arrays, in which an officer not directly investigating a case shows a witness photos of potential suspects. Exceptions can be made with the permission of a supervisor.
Mr. Campbell said Detective Sherwood got permission from a sergeant to administer the photo array, even though she was working the case, because no one else was around. But the attorney would not identify the sergeant, reveal whether his account jibed with Detective Sherwood’s or say whether he, too, was disciplined.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com, 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @rczullo. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.