Thousands of households in Pittsburgh’s south and west neighborhoods could face higher water bills as the city shores up its biggest water utility.
For more than 40 years, families and businesses from Fairywood and Sheraden southeast to New Homestead and Lincoln Place have paid discounted rates under the city’s arrangement with Pennsylvania American Water Co., the private-sector water utility supplying those areas. A multi-million-dollar subsidy paid by the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, which serves most of the city, keeps pricing identical across the two service areas.
That subsidy should vanish to help PWSA bolster its shaky finances, according to a blue-ribbon panel that’s exploring how to mend the troubled municipal authority. The recommendation appears among the group’s seven ideas for PWSA operations, such as ditching free water for city facilities and nixing a longtime residency requirement for authority workers.
Still, the prospect of new water pricing rankled city Councilman Anthony Coghill, whose South Hills district includes Beechview and Brookline.
“If the plan is simply dropping the subsidy to Pennsylvania American customers so we get to pay higher rates over here — that, to me, is no plan at all,” Mr. Coghill said. He said he thought the idea was a literal joke.
Panel member Alex W. Thomson, a former PWSA board president, wasn’t laughing. He said it didn’t make sense to him that “a public authority should be subsidizing a private company.” Mayor Bill Peduto, who appointed the panel last year, said PWSA needs more than $2 billion in infrastructure work.
It also counts nearly $1 billion more in debt.
“I just don’t think, from an equitable standpoint, that it makes sense that a PWSA water customer pays more so that a Pennsylvania American customer can pay less — especially given the nature of the two systems in terms of the infrastructure and capital needs of the PWSA system,” Mr. Thomson said.
PWSA paid Pennsylvania American nearly $5 million for the three years that ended in December 2016, a state audit found. Auditor General Eugene DePasquale recommended in November that PWSA “reduce and ultimately close the subsidy gap.”
Should the city drop the subsidy, the 27,000 Pennsylvania American customers in Pittsburgh would face the company’s standard rates for tap water, spokesman Gary Lobaugh confirmed in a statement.
Pennsylvania American customers outside city limits already pay those prices, which appeared around 25 percent higher than PWSA rates in an analysis by Pennsylvania American. The calculation assumed average residential use of 3,000 gallons a month.
Because PWSA and Pennsylvania American differ in their billing methodology, it’s tough to calculate a direct pricing comparison. PWSA charges typical residential customers $23.25 a month for their first 1,000 gallons, then $9.41 for each 1,000 gallons thereafter. Pennsylvania American charges similar customers outside the city a $16.50 monthly service fee and about $1.22 per 100 gallons. The figures include only tap water, not sewage charges, which are additional.
“The discount provided to City of Pittsburgh customers was a decision made by city leaders more than 45 years ago and not by Pennsylvania American Water,” Mr. Lobaugh said. The company “implements the savings at their request,” according to his statement.
He said Pennsylvania American offers an assistance program to help qualified customers. The company’s rates, regulated by the state Public Utility Commission, “reflect the true cost of service and the significant capital investments that we make in our infrastructure,” Mr. Lobaugh said.
By 2020, PWSA rates are set to rise about 50 percent over 2017 prices to help finance long-neglected upkeep in the authority’s leak- and failure-prone system. PWSA has issued four boil-water advisories since last winter.
But it’s likely to be months before any major changes in policy or governance take effect at the authority. Mr. Peduto has told the blue-ribbon panel to seek outside counsel and pursue its suggested changes to PWSA governance, including a new Board of Nominators. A self-perpetuating group, that board would choose a new PWSA Board of Directors to oversee policy and operations.
Mr. Peduto told the panel to draw up a contract — between the city and PWSA — by March 31 that would foster such governance changes, which are likely to require city council’s involvement. He said the Pennsylvania American subsidy, and how it might be unraveled, will be among the questions studied.
“I think we have to address every one of these issues,” Mr. Peduto said, referring to the city’s own fiscal arrangement with PWSA, the Pennsylvania American subsidy and other financial concerns. “These are all legacies that have caused disinvestment into an asset which has borrowed beyond its capacity and still was not able to have enough money to keep its operations running.”
He didn’t claim a specific position on the subsidy but said the city needs to consider PWSA’s financial practices holistically to foment “a fairer system over time.”
Under longtime practices, the mayor appoints — and city council confirms — PWSA board members. Under the plan for a nominators board, neither future mayors nor council members would be involved in the process. Advocates have said the vision is to prevent undue political meddling and encourage stable oversight.
Council members have begun pushing back, arguing that they serve as the people’s voice and watchdog. At a public meeting Tuesday, several critics chafed at what they called a shortfall of public accountability and involvement in the nominators idea. Mr. Thomson said he found merit in the concerns and that “we’ll certainly consider those.”
“The improvements that PWSA has to make are not [going to take] two years. They’re going to take 10 years,” he said. “We want to give them governance that allows [PWSA] to stay focused and doesn’t change on the election cycle.”
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.