A federal drug and murder case will proceed after a judge on Wednesday ruled that wiretap evidence gathered by state agents in 2014 will be allowed as part of the prosecution.

In a lengthy opinion, U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak denied defense motions to suppress recordings from a tap of Price Montgomery's cell phone.

Montgomery, 36, of Mount Washington, is accused of gunning down Tina Crawford in the Hill District on Aug. 22, 2014, shortly before she was to meet with federal prosecutors about his alleged heroin operation.

Montgomery and his accused co-conspirators are under indictment in U.S. District Court on drug distribution charges. He is also charged with killing a federal witness.

Advertise with us

Lawyers for Montgomery and two cohorts, James Perrin and Charles Cook, had challenged the legality of the wiretaps because they said the order authorizing them wasn't properly signed by the state attorney general at the time, Kathleen Kane, or by someone she designated to act in her place while she traveled in Haiti.

The U.S. attorney's office had argued that Kane’s first deputy, Adrian King, was authorized under state law to sign the wiretap application in her absence. The judge, who held three days of hearings on the issue in June, agreed.

In his ruling, he said he concluded that “Pennsylvania law has intended for the absence provision of the Administrative Code to allow the First Deputy AG to execute the non-excluded duties of the AG, including executing a wiretap application, during an AG's absence.”

He said the provision “is particularly important in just this sort of case, where the AG is unexpectedly (or perhaps more precisely in this case, somewhat mysteriously) absent in circumstances fraught with uncertainty as to her whereabouts and accessibility, there is no written designation, and the business of the AG's Office — in this case, the process of executing a time-sensitive wiretap application — cannot grind to a halt for an indeterminate period of time.”

The lawyers had challenged the tap on other grounds as well, the judge said, most of them based on the idea that the application was not legally authorized.

Advertise with us

He denied them all and the case will now proceed in federal court.

Montgomery's lawyer, Douglas Sughrue, said he hadn’t had time to review the ruling and had no comment. The other lawyers in the case didn’t respond to a message.

Under state law, the attorney general is the person who authorizes an application for a wiretap. If the AG isn't available, he can designate someone to do it. But that designation is supposed to be in writing.

When state drug agents were investigating Montgomery in April 2014, they wanted to tap his phone and needed Kane to sign the application. But she was in Haiti and no one could reach her.

Her assistant, Kathryn Smith, had prepared a letter designating Mr. King as acting AG while Kane was gone. But Kane never signed it. Instead, she told Smith if the need arose, Smith could sign on her behalf.

Advertise with us

When it was time to authorize the tap, Smith tried to reach Kane in Haiti but couldn’t. So King told Smith to sign the letter designating him as the acting AG, and he then signed the application.

A month later, the office used parts of the original application to seek an extension of the tap, which Kane did sign.

King testified at the hearings in June and said he spoke with Kane on April 13 and thought it was clear that she approved seeking the authorization.

But Kane, who was convicted in 2016 of perjury, obstruction, conspiracy and false swearing, refused to confirm that or answer any questions when she was called to testify by Montgomery's lawyers.

The wiretap evidence is crucial to the U.S. attorney’s prosecution of Montgomery.

Advertise with us

Had the defense succeeded in suppressing the taps, the government’s drug counts against Montgomery and Perrin would be in jeopardy. The part of the case pertaining to the murder and other counts of soliciting cohorts to kill additional witnesses might not have been affected, although no one could say for certain.

The U.S. attorney's office does not comment on pending cases.