Thousands of Pittsburghers have relied on free kits to check for lead in their tap water, most finding the dangerous metal either undetectable or below a key threshold for action.

Still, figures shared by the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority show participation and test results under the public health program vary widely among neighborhoods. While Highland Park, Shadyside, Squirrel Hill and Greenfield have logged hundreds of results apiece since winter 2016, portions of Homewood, the North Side and the Hill District have struggled to approach even a fraction of that.

The gap underscores a basic lack of information in historically disenfranchised communities, said T. Rashad Byrdsong, an activist and CEO at the Community Empowerment Association in Homewood.

“We’ve got to make sure we educate our community,” said Mr. Byrdsong, who urged better outreach to encourage more lead tests in under-participating neighborhoods. And “there has got to be some oversight.”

Advertise with us

At the Our Water Campaign, a coalition that’s gone door to door with sign-ups for test kits, organizer Aly Shaw said awareness is improving. She agreed PWSA could do more to spread the word.

“It is difficult for people who might have a few jobs or other things on their mind to go through this whole process of testing their water,” Ms. Shaw said. “A lot of people just say, ‘I’ll buy a water filter or get a free filter somewhere, just to be safe.’”

Certified lead filters can reduce contamination risks, but they won’t help reveal lead sources that may fester for years. The test kits offered by PWSA can detect lead from a home’s indoor plumbing or its service line, the exterior connection that ties indoor pipes into a water main beneath the street.

“We’re using [the results], to some extent, to figure out where there are lead service lines,” said Robert Weimar, the PWSA interim executive director. He said some properties with more concentrated lead results “are where we’re going to do some of our [line] replacements.”

The authority “will do everything we can to provide the opportunity for [people] to know” their lead levels, Mr. Weimar pledged, “and to be able to get the assistance that they need to provide the optimum health benefits.”

Advertise with us

PWSA also is inspecting curb boxes — an exterior access point for service connections — and combing records to locate lead service lines, the target of a state order in 2016. The authority must replace 7 percent of its lead lines each year until separate compliance checks show sustained declines in lead results, according to the mandate. PWSA has estimated around 18,000 residential service connections, about a quarter of the total, likely contain the metal.

Reaching the masses

Meanwhile, the authority contracted a water quality expert to help bolster the resident test kit program and its reach, officials said. They’re exploring how to make the test process less cumbersome, too. Residents now should let water stagnate six hours in their pipes before they draw a sample, then mail it away for results.

PWSA has marketed the program since spring 2016, including through special mailings and community meetings. Mr. Weimar said “it’s not for a lack of trying” that participation isn’t better.

“The authority has partnered with several community organizations to promote the lead test kit program and solicit test kit requests,” spokesman Will Pickering said in a statement. “Specifically, PWSA is coordinating with Women for a Healthy Environment to collect lead test kit requests.”

Advertise with us

Kits are available to PWSA customers and other Pittsburghers, including renters, by calling 412-255-2423 or sending email to servicelines@pgh2o.com. PWSA advertises the kits in service bills, although those statements often do not reach customers who have landlords.

“I still don’t think it’s been well publicized at all,” said Chie Togami, 26, of Hazelwood. She called herself “really lucky that we didn’t have any lead” in her test results.

She heard about the program through a friend in the Our Water Campaign, but probably wouldn’t have known otherwise, Ms. Togami said. She suggested billboards or advertisements at bus stops.

Allegheny County health Director Karen Hacker praised the program overall, saying PWSA is “doing what they should be doing.” She called it a challenge for many agencies to focus public concern on lead, which can turn up in old paint, soil and other sources.

She knew of no lead poisoning cases in Pittsburgh where contaminated water was the primary source, Dr. Hacker said.

Advertise with us

"While water may not be the primary sources of lead exposure in our investigations, it should be considered a source and residents should get their water tested, use filters and/or bottled water, particularly for infants and pregnant women," she said in a statement.

Speeding the process

Back at PWSA, managers are planning to bring lead test processing in-house from outside vendors, a switch that could reduce wait times to fewer than 10 days for results. That’s down from as many as six weeks now.

“A lot of people are getting these [water] test kits and are likely reading the instructions,” Mr. Pickering said. “And it’s a pain in the butt, and you forget about it.”

People returned perhaps fewer than half the test kits they’ve requested from PWSA over the past couple years, according to authority estimates. Among those that customers sent in for processing, roughly 93 percent showed either no detectable lead or findings beneath the federal Environmental Protection Agency’s action level. That’s according to PWSA data covering more than 7,000 samples from February 2016 to September 2017.

Advertise with us

Tests exceed EPA’s action level for lead As many as 15 percent of tests in heavily tested Pittsburgh neighborhoods from February 2016 to September 2017 found lead at more than 15 parts per billion. That’s the level at which federal authorities advise limiting exposure. Neighborhood, percent over 15 ppb

Created with Highstock 6.0.43636161623234646444464641515992828232329291818242477111166663366229229122122227227465465463463706706178178108108347347287287381381253253359359107107176176121121125125106106227227Number of tests over 15 ppbTotal number of testsMount Washington: 15.72%Perry North: 13.11%Brighton Heights: 10.13%Point Breeze: 9.89%Squirrel Hill North: 9.50%Squirrel Hill South: 9.07%Morningside: 8.43%Southside Slopes: 8.33%Highland Park: 8.07%Bloomfield: 8.01%Shadyside: 7.61%Central Lawrenceville: 7.11%Greenfield: 6.69%Hazelwood: 6.54%Southside Flats: 6.25%Millvale: 4.96%East Liberty: 4.80%Central Northside: 2.83%Stanton Heights: 2.64%0100200300400500600700800

Source: PWSA; Research: Christopher Huffaker, Graphic: Ed Yozwick/Post-Gazette

Lead test results vary widely by neighborhood

Average lead parts per billion by neighborhood, for neighborhoods with at least 25 results.

Note: While most of the city receives tap water from PWSA, some areas do not. Southern and western neighborhoods such as Crafton Heights, Carrick, Sheraden, Westwood, Beechview, Brookline and Lincoln Place receive water from Pennsylvania American Water Co., while a small number of others are served by West View Water Authority or the Wilkinsburg-Penn Joint Water Authority.

Advertise with us

About 7 percent eclipsed the action level, which is 15 parts per billion. With lead at that concentration or higher, residents should take steps to limit exposure until the lead source is identified and eliminated, according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Precautions include running a faucet on cold for a minute or two before using water for drinking or cooking, especially if the water has been off more than six hours, the CDC advises. Certified filters can help, as well. Research links lead exposure to myriad ailments, such as developmental problems and kidney damage.

Mr. Weimar said it’s expected that average lead levels — as measured through resident test kits, at least — vary among neighborhoods. Introduced at the water plant, chemical treatments to discourage pipe corrosion can settle unevenly in the distribution system, Mr. Weimar said. PWSA is investigating whether different additives would be more effective.

Other variables include just how well people follow the test instructions, Mr. Weimar said.

“We would like to think the public has enough wherewithal to deal with basic instructions, but for whatever reason some people, I guess, feel the need to vary from what we’ve asked them to do,” he said. “Sometimes you can’t tell whether those results are of real value because they may not be done in the same way the others have been.”

Advertise with us

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz. Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, @huffakingit.

Correction: An earlier version of this story contained a graphic with incorrect information.