Mayor Bill Peduto signed a hotly contested bill into law late Thursday that makes it illegal to use a whip, electric prod or elephant hook on any wild or exotic animal in Pittsburgh.
The bill, which outlaws the use of any instrument "capable of inflicting pain, intimidating or threatening pain for the purpose of training or controlling" wild and exotic animals, has been heavily opposed by the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium and Syria Shrine, which runs the annual Shrine Circus at PPG Paints Arena.
Shrine Circus officials have publicly condemned the bill for being too broad and putting the circus through needless regulations, while zoo officials have argued that the legislation would prevent the zoo from safely using tools that protect caretakers, the animals and the public.
Violators can face a fine as high as $1,000 and up to 30 days in jail.
Though the impact the bill will have on the 68-year-old fundraising circus is to be determined, Shrine Circus Chairman Paul Leavy said the circus has contracts in place through September 2018 with its performers and PPG Paints Arena and is “awaiting a decision on whether we’re a ‘go’ or not.”
Mr. Leavy, who met with the mayor’s chief of staff this week, said the circus does not condone the mistreatment of animals, and wants the proper tools to “faithfully and legally guide” its animals.
Read More
“It makes it look like we're asking permission to abuse animals and that's certainly not the case at all,” Mr. Leavy said. “We have been coming here for almost seven decades and have had zero issues.”
The bill was originally proposed by City Council President Bruce Kraus and passed by council Dec. 19 on a 6-3 vote. Its backers included animal protection activists from organizations like Humane Action Pittsburgh, who praised the mayor for signing it.
"I think this just really solidifies Pittsburgh's position in history as a progressive city, a compassionate city, and everything we strive for," Natalie Ahwesh, the group's vice president, said Friday.
Mr. Kraus said in early December that his bill was not meant to keep the circus from Pittsburgh, but to "raise the awareness of the public at large that there is a completely different conversation taking place over how we breed, cage, train and transport animals for our entertainment value.”
Both the zoo and circus took issue with wording in the bill, and sought, unsuccessfully, a legislative amendment to ban "improper use" of tools.
The ordinance specifically outlaws the use of a bullhook, electric prod, shocking device, hacksaw, ankus, ankusha, elephant goad, elephant hook, baseball bat, axe handle, pitchfork, whip, stick and muzzle on wild and exotic animals -- a list that Mr. Leavy said is mostly for “shock value.”
“We just have to have the tools that are required to do our jobs,” he said. “I don't need baseball bats and hacksaws and pitchforks.”
Before the bill was passed by council, the zoo argued that it is already regulated by federal laws, and that the city ordinance would restrict some tools that are "professionally recognized by wildlife caregivers" and others that have never even been used by the zoo.
A spokeswoman for the zoo declined comment Friday and referred to the zoo’s previously documented position.
Ms. Ahwesh said her group, which is meeting with zoo officials next week, has reached out to the circus for two years without success.
"We were never out to get the circus or to get the zoo, but we can't tolerate animal abuse, especially in 2017," Ms. Ahwesh said. "We really hope our organization can work with the [circus] and work with the zoo to see how we can have a win-win for everyone. But the animals can't lose."
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.