City legislation targeting the treatment of wild and exotic animals would “effectively end” the Shrine Circus in Pittsburgh, circus Chairman Paul Leavy warned Thursday, saying the proposal blindsided organizers this week.

“We were as surprised as anybody,” said Mr. Leavy, who leads the Syria Shrine’s 68-year-old fundraising circus at PPG Paints Arena. The next one, including elephants and other animals, is slated for September.

A bill brought up Wednesday by City Council President Bruce Kraus would outlaw using an electric prod, whip or bullhook to manage any wild or exotic animal. The measure would extend to any instrument “capable of inflicting pain, intimidating, threatening pain or mimicking any such device,” banning their use in controlling or training the animals.

“I believe history will prove us to be right in the actions that we’re taking,” Mr. Kraus said Thursday. “There’s a clear culture shift in the way animals are used in entertainment and not just here in Pittsburgh [but] nationally. I think we’re a little late to the table.”

Advertise with us

His legislation would prevent such implements from being displayed near the wildlife, too. But the circus’ insurance carriers require the presence of bullhooks in certain circumstances involving elephants, Mr. Leavy said. He called that a standard practice approved by a host of regulators and professional associations, adding that animals at the circus don’t undergo any pain or harm.

Bullhooks typically feature a pointed hook atop a long handle. The implement “is not used to gouge our elephants or anything like that. It is simply used as a guide,” if it’s used at all, Mr. Leavy said. He said tools are crucial “for the safe and humane movement and transportation of performing animals.”

Council is expected to vote Tuesday on the legislation. Mr. Kraus, who describes himself as a longtime advocate for the humane treatment of animals, said the push follows similar policies in Richmond, Va., Pompano Beach and Miami Beach, Fla., and other cities. California and Rhode Island have banned bullhooks’ use entirely.

The local proposal replaces a broader bill that Mr. Kraus floated in 2016, when he sought to halt performances of wild and exotic animals for public entertainment. Opponents worried the plan would undermine circus acts.

Mr. Kraus didn’t have enough votes on council to pass that bill, but he expects more support for the latest, narrower pitch, he said. He said the city law department fully vetted the document.

Advertise with us

He declined to speak much to Mr. Leavy’s statements, saying that he is “not privy to any contractual obligations they may have” with insurance carriers. He said he doesn't intend to force out the circus.

“Law is comfortable with it, and I am comfortable with it,” Mr. Kraus said of the bill.

Still, the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium hopes council will take more time with the matter, zoo spokeswoman Tracy Gray has said. In a statement Wednesday, she said the zoo had received documentation about the legislation that day.

“Having had limited time to review the document, we have preliminary questions and areas of concern we would like to discuss further with the council,” Ms. Gray said.

Mr. Kraus signaled that he still plans to have a council vote Tuesday. His office first contacted the zoo Nov. 20 about the bill, he said.

Advertise with us

At Mayor Bill Peduto’s office, spokesman Timothy McNulty said he didn’t think Mr. Peduto had yet studied the legislation. It arose at a marathon meeting that ran some five hours Wednesday.

“We’ll review anything if and when something is approved” by council, Mr. McNulty said.

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.