The lyrics talked about Glocks and bullets and knowing where two specific police officers slept.
It referenced the Stanton Heights man convicted of killing three Pittsburgh police officers in 2009.
It included the words: “Let’s kill these cops ’cause they don’t do us no good.”
Now, the state Supreme Court must decide if that rap song is protected free speech under the First Amendment or if it constituted a “true threat” that properly resulted in a criminal conviction for terroristic threats and witness intimidation.
The case, brought by Jamal Knox, one of two men that wrote and performed the song, will be argued before Pennsylvania’s highest court on Tuesday in Harrisburg.
Depending on the court’s ruling, there is potential the case could ultimately end up before the U.S. Supreme Court.
“This is a contextual blend of perhaps the most salient domestic social issue of our time,” wrote Patrick Nightingale, Knox’s attorney. “In this context and at this time in the history of our nation and commonwealth, the question of whether Knox's conduct is protected by the First Amendment or is punishable by criminal sanction hardly could be of more substantial importance.”
Knox, 23, and Rashee Beasley, 26, wrote and performed their song in 2012, and someone — they say it wasn’t them — uploaded it to YouTube in November of that year. Shortly thereafter, they were charged by Pittsburgh police who construed the song’s lyrics as threats made specifically against Det. Daniel Zeltner and Officer Michael Kosko, both of whom had previously arrested the men.
Following a nonjury trial before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, both men were found guilty, and in February 2014, Knox was ordered to serve two to six years in state prison. He was released in December 2016.
Knox appealed his conviction to the state Superior Court, which upheld it last year. But the state Supreme Court agreed to hear the case based solely on the issue of whether the song qualifies as a threat under the case law or if it is protected free speech.
Mr. Nightingale said there was no evidence at trial that Knox intended to communicate a threat of violence against the officers.
“The song was artistic in nature. As a gangster rap artist, Knox considered himself a poet, musician, and entertainer,” his attorney wrote. “Rap music served as his vehicle for self-expression, self-realization, economic gain, inspiring pride and respect from their peers, and speaking on public issues including police violence, on behalf of him and others who may lack the courage or ability to speak on such issues.
“Threatening police was not the intent of Knox's expression.”
Under U.S. Supreme Court precedent, Mr. Nightingale wrote, “true threats are ‘those statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals.’”
To even be considered a threat, he continued, the words need to be conveyed either directly or indirectly to the person in question. There must be a conscious action taken.
In this case, he continued, that never happened. Neither Knox nor Beasley uploaded the song to YouTube, and, Mr. Nightingale said, there was never proof presented that they intended for the officers to hear it.
But Assistant District Attorney Francesco Nepa said in his brief that the state Supreme Court denied review on the question of whether there was evidence that Knox uploaded the song, and that that issue should not even be considered.
In referencing the same U.S. Supreme Court precedent as Knox, Mr. Nepa said that it does not require the speaker to actually intend to carry out the threat but instead is meant to protect the targets from “from the fear of violence” and “from the disruption that fear engenders,” as well as protect them “from the possibility that the threatened violence will occur.”
In this case, he continued, the officers said that they felt fearful when they heard the lyrics.
When they first arrested Knox and Beasley, there was a loaded firearm in their car, “making the threats of violence expressed in the song that much more real,” Mr. Nepa wrote, and the officers were still witnesses in the case against them at the time the song was written,
“Furthermore, Kosko and Zeltner both actually testified that they were concerned for their safety as a result of the language contained in the lyrics, with Kosko going so far as to say that the video was in part responsible for his decision to leave the Pittsburgh Police, and it was also established that additional personnel were deployed within the department so as to provide the two officers with extra security.”
Based on all those circumstances, Mr. Nepa wrote, the song is a true threat that deserves no First Amendment protection.
There are limits to art, and just because something is characterized as “’artistic creation’ does not give its creator license to say anything that he wants without fear of repercussion,” the prosecutor wrote.
But in a friend-of-the-court brief, the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania wrote that artistic expression is often disturbing, offensive and shocking.
“This is especially true of rap, Knox’s musical genre,” attorneys wrote. “As scholars of the genre have described it, rap is a form of political expression that gives voice to urban poverty, street crime, and limited life options, and a criminal justice system that sweeps up young men of color.”
To determine if the song represents a true threat, the ACLU brief continued, the court must determine the defendant’s state of mind.
“A review of the record reveals that the commonwealth did not meet this standard, failing to establish that Knox intentionally, with purpose, expressed and communicated a terroristic threat.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.