Pennsylvania environmental regulators slapped the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority with a $2.4 million penalty, scolding the utility over an unauthorized change in treatment chemicals, a failure to replace enough lead water pipes and other shortfalls.

Under an agreement announced Friday, the state Department of Environmental Protection said up to $1.8 million from the penalty could go toward “community improvements,” such as private lead service line replacements for low-income homeowners. PWSA pledged to accelerate the state-ordered removal of lead lines after it missed an initial deadline.

“Typically, a community environmental project accounts for not more than half of a penalty assessment,” said Ron Schwartz, the DEP acting southwest regional director, in a statement. “But we felt that this situation warranted a much more robust effort to assist homeowners, upgrade the system and restore public trust in the water that flows from their faucets.”

PWSA “acknowledges the missteps of the past” and has “either already corrected them or has work underway that will address them as soon as possible,” said Robert Weimar, the authority’s interim executive director. Board Chairwoman Debbie Lestitian said the agreement, expected for months, provides “a clear road map for how the authority will remove lead from our water system.”

Advertise with us

Problems cited by DEP stretch back several years. In summer 2016, the department ordered PWSA to replace 7 percent of its lead service lines each year after water tests found elevated levels of the hazardous metal. The uptick followed a 2014 change in the chemical treatment that PWSA uses to prevent pipe corrosion, an adjustment that may have contributed to lead contamination.

PWSA failed to obtain a permit for the treatment switch, according to DEP. It also failed to complete the 1,341 lead service line replacements that DEP had expected by June 30, finishing only 415, regulators noted.

A service line connects each building to a water main beneath the street. PWSA has estimated that as many as 17,750 of 71,000 residential service connections contain lead.

Mr. Weimar attributed the replacement shortfall to several factors, including early delays in lining up contractors and locating lead lines. It wasn’t until September 2016 that authorities firmed up the first-year goal for replacements, he said.

Plus, PWSA announced in mid-2017 that it would halt a practice known as partial line replacement, which involves removing only a portion of a lead connection. Each service line includes a public portion owned by PWSA, and a private portion — owned by the property owner — that finishes the connection into the building.

Advertise with us

The DEP mandate affects only the public lead lines, which can run about $6,000 per replacement. When the private side also is lead, contamination risks may increase temporarily if workers do not remove the entire connection. That’s known as a partial replacement.

PWSA’s resistance to partial replacements contributed to its penalty, but “the board stands by our decision to halt [the] potentially harmful” practice, Ms. Lestitian said. Of the 415 service lines replaced through June 30, 225 were partials, many spurred by emergency work, according to PWSA.

Still, PWSA completed partials for at least 60 residences without providing sufficient advance notice, another shortcoming documented by DEP. For nearly 150 homes, the authority failed to collect water samples within 72 hours after partial work. PWSA didn’t contest those DEP findings but said it supplied filters and test kits to all homes with partial line work.

Going forward, Mr. Weimar said PWSA won’t perform partial replacements except in emergencies. The DEP agreement calls for at least 1,341 total line replacements by June 30, 2018.

Meanwhile, the authority and policymakers are working toward assistance to help lower-income households replace their private service lines, undercutting any need for partial replacements. Private-side work can run a few thousand dollars.

Advertise with us

PWSA also is investigating additives that could better prevent lead contamination across the system. If approved by regulators, an orthophosphate treatment introduced next year would probably reduce lead below a key federal threshold, according to authority projections.

That could end the mandatory lead line replacements, which were triggered under a federal rule. Under that scenario, Mr. Weimar said PWSA would keep removing the lines but at a slower pace, swapping them out in conjunction with the replacement of water mains. He said the approach would be more efficient.

“We’re confident that once we get the elixir applied, and that it gets an opportunity to migrate throughout the system, problems are going to go away,” Mr. Weimar said. “But that doesn’t mean we’re going to stop doing service line replacements.”

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625, @asmeltz.