Pulitzer Prize-winning New York Times columnist James B. Stewart puts Pittsburgh first in the running for the new Amazon headquarters.

It’s neither the biggest nor the brightest competitor... but that’s kind of the point.

Mr. Stewart acknowledges that with 238 cities chasing after Amazon’s promised 50,000 jobs and $5 billion in construction, it’s become “a nationwide parlor game of picking a winner.” He also acknowledges some heavyweight number-crunchers disagree with him: “Moody’s Analytics has already crowned Austin, Tex. The New York Times Upshot chose Denver.”

Why does Mr. Stewart think Pittsburgh has the best shot?

Advertise with us

It’s a combination of things, based on what he thinks Amazon values most.

Location: 

“Amazon prides itself on having its existing headquarters embedded in the urban fabric of Seattle,” notes Mr. Stewart. “The idea of inhabiting the sort of self-contained suburban corporate parks so common in Silicon Valley seems anathema to Amazon.”

He notes that cities like Boston, Washington, and San Francisco rank higher in the number of people who walk or ride a bike to work, but Pittsburgh has been making the right noises and moving the the right direction. What’s more, he says:

“Cities like Pittsburgh, Detroit and Baltimore are rich in underutilized historic buildings and neighborhoods that could be imaginatively repurposed, offering Amazon the opportunity to be a transformative force, something that seems to be part of the company’s DNA.”

Pittsburgh is malleable.

Advertise with us

Incentives:

It’s more than tax breaks offered up by the various locations - reportedly $7 billion worth for Newark, NJ - Mr. Stewart says: There’s a “cost of living” for businesses that differs from city to city, and places like Newark and its hulking neighbor across the Hudson are well above the national baseline.

“The lowest-cost American cities are mostly in the Sunbelt; Austin’s score is 96.2. But many older industrial cities also offer cost advantages: Cincinnati (94), Baltimore (96.5), Pittsburgh (97), Chicago (98.3) and Philadelphia (99.8) are all below the baseline.”

Pittsburgh is - relatively speaking - a bargain.

Talent:

Pittsburgh doesn’t rank at the top of “tech talent” in the country, but neither does it rank toward the bottom - Mr Stewart says - it’s in a Goldilocks spot somewhere in the middle with cities like Detroit and Philadelphia.

Advertise with us

The city has multiple universities, and their graduates don’t mind sticking around after they get the diploma.

Transportation:

This is the sticky one. “Logistics” - specifically direct flights to Seattle - are “critically important,” according to Amazon. But this doesn’t seem to faze Mr. Stewart; in fact, he implies the struggles at the airport since the departure of USAir may actually be an advantage:

“Pittsburgh lacks nonstop flights to Seattle and offers only limited nonstop service to international destinations. But the city was once a major hub for US Air, which made substantial investments in infrastructure there before it was taken over by American Airlines. The number of flights to and from Pittsburgh has dwindled since then, but they could easily be revived.”

Unlike other recent love-songs the Times has sung to Pittsburgh, Mr. Stewart doesn’t dwell on the city’s advantages. He simply puts it first:

“There are obviously many variables still to be assessed, but based on these criteria and the weight I expect Amazon to place on them, here are my finalists, in descending order: Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Philadelphia, Toronto, Chicago and Boston.”

Many in Pittsburgh, including Mayor Bill Peduto, hope he’s right.