All Kevin Saftner wants is to have a conversation. The problem is, he doesn’t know who he’d be having it with.

His business, the James Street Gastropub & Speakeasy, an iconic tavern and music venue on the North Side, is on the verge of closing after the State police Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement has cited the business numerous times in response to anonymous complaints from a neighbor or neighbors for noise violations going back more than a year.

“It’s all anonymous, and I understand that individuals need protection,” he said. “But we’re a family business. All we would love to do is know who it is so we can talk to them and try to solve this.”

But since he doesn’t know who’s doing the complaining, he can’t rectify the situation more than he already has. Last year, he installed sound proofing and an air-conditioning system so that windows in the upstairs ballroom don’t have to be opened during performances in the stifling summer heat.

Advertise with us

“We’ve gone to community meetings and we’ve spoken to everyone around here, but no one has ever come to us and said ‘I have an issue, let’s discuss this.’ ”

After he learned that another complaint was lodged last week during a regular jazz jam session gig by veteran local musician Roger Humphries, who has been playing that room for years, he posted on Facebook that he’d had enough, and would close the James Street on Nov. 11.

“After a year and a half, we’re not able to rectify it, and that’s all we’ve wanted to do,” he said.

Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto weighed in on the topic after a press conference Thursday morning.

“We’re at least going to try to mediate between the neighbors and the business itself,” Mr. Peduto said. “James Street is a part of Pittsburgh’s history, lore — it’s a critical component to our jazz scene. And we aren’t asking the neighbors to have to sacrifice and be able to live with a constant presence of noise. But at the same time, we want to be able to see what we can do to minimize any negative impact and be able to make sure that the James Street tavern remains a part of Pittsburgh’s fabric.”

Advertise with us

According to the online PLCB license database, James Street has officially been cited twice since Mr. Saftner and his mother, Lisa, took control of the business six years ago: once in January 2016 and again in July of this year. Mr. Saftner said that he was informed that two more citations are headed his way, although they can take months to process.

The fines thus far total $600, but the money isn’t the issue — it’s the specter of being labeled a nuisance bar, which would impact his liquor license and what businesses could operate in the building.

“We want to cut our losses before they become really big losses.”

He has no harsh words for the BLCE or the undercover agents that have visited him.

“They’re super cool. They feel bad,” but “They said they’re getting calls all the time.”

Advertise with us

A potential solution he said, would be to limit live music to the basement speakeasy and use the top floor for private events — except for one caveat: he’s in business to be a music venue, not to be a catering hall.

“That would be starting a brand new business and I don’t know that thing,” he said. “We just don’t have that in us.”

The James Street’s main floor back bar is among the most handsome in the city. A phalanx of lions carved into the tops of the African mahogany cabinetry that was carved by a neighborhood craftsman in 1926 (during Prohibition) for the then-princely sum of $3,000. It was part of an upstairs speakeasy — now the main ballroom — and was later brought down piece by piece and reconstructed in the downstairs space where it now sits.

Craig Poole, who owned it for 17 years as the James St. Tavern, said that Art Rooney Sr. once also owned the building, which dates at least to 1898 (the original deeds were destroyed in a fire). Founded as a bicycle and clock shop, the top floor was once also a secret meeting spot for socialist and labor groups.

In the decades since, it’s had many names, notably Wiggin’s, Julian’s and the James St. Tavern — where legends such as George Benson, Stanley Turrentine, Jeffrey Osborne and the Preservation Hall Jazz Band graced the stage.

Advertise with us

Ray Schubert, 70, said he’s lived across the street from the tavern his entire life. His house faces the ballroom windows that have been the source of the complaints.

“They did all that work over there, put all that money into there — there’s no problem,” he said Thursday afternoon. “None whatsoever. I just had cancer surgery. My wife is handicapped. They come over and help me keep up my property. I got no problem whatsoever. It’s 100 percent better. They went above and beyond to fix it.”

Mr. Schubert said that state agents knocked on his door and left forms if he had a complaint.

“I wouldn’t even fill them out,” he said.

Cody Walters is the Main Street Director for the North Side Leadership Conference and said that he hasn't heard of any neighbors complaining since the James Street made noise remediation efforts last year.

Advertise with us

"If anyone said anything bad, I would know about it," he said adding that it could be someone with a personal ax to grind.

"I’m skeptical that it is actually a neighbor that's complaining," he said. "The problem under the code is that if you have a liquor license and someone complains, they have to go inspect it, and the state police go by the letter of the law. Under ordinance, if you can hear amplified sound when you step off the sidewalk you're in violation - any bar anywhere has that."

Mr. Walters gave a hypothetical example that if the James Street was a coffee shop it could blast loud music all night until 11 p.m. if they so desired. But because they are a liquor purveyor, they are subject to stricter rules.

"We’re sad to see them go," Mr. Walters said, noting that cities as disparate as Austin, Texas and London have lost scores of venues after neighborhoods have seen increased development.

Mr. Walters, who co-founded the annual Deutschtown Music Festival - of which the James Street has been an integral part as a host venue, said that the issue is part of a larger conversation.

Advertise with us

"This creates an opportunity to have a conversation – are we or are we not going to be a music city? This could happen in any neighborhood."

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412