When Danny Kelly, the youngest of the North Side’s famed Kelly brothers, was captured in North Korea in late November 1950, his family here clung to the hope that one day he would come back home.

On Monday, his remains -- unearthed in a dig in 2005 -- will arrive at Pittsburgh International Airport, escorted by an Army honor guard and welcomed by relatives who barely remember him.

“We always hoped. He’s always been on our minds,” said Cheryl Gentile, 70, of Valencia, who was only 3 years old when her Uncle Danny went missing in action. “None of us have ever forgotten him. We all have talked about him through the years.”

Daniel Francis Kelly

“I remember when I was little, my mother would tell me, ‘Say a prayer for Uncle Danny,’” said Sue Donovan, 69, of Allison Park. “And we said our prayers for him.”

Advertise with us

As far as they are concerned, their prayers have been answered. Danny is coming home.

Daniel Francis Kelly grew up idolizing his eight older brothers -- Howard, Eugene, James, Frank, John, Edward, George and Charles, all of whom enlisted in the Army before him. All but Howard served during World War II and returned as heroes, especially Charles “Chuck” Kelly, who was immortalized nationwide as “Commando Kelly.”

Sgt. Chuck Kelly was the first soldier in the European war theater to receive the nation's highest military award for valor -- the Medal of Honor -- and was one of the most celebrated military heroes of World War II. He single-handedly fought off a German platoon, killing 40 enemy troops while enabling his own detachment to escape from Altavilla, Italy, on Sept. 1, 1943.

When he returned in April 1944, he and his mother, Irene, rode in an open car during a parade through Downtown Pittsburgh. A photo in the archives of Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hall and Museum shows 11-year-old Danny seated with them.

There is another photo that the Kelly family holds dear. It’s a black-and-white image showing three of the brothers -- John, George and Eugene -- strolling proudly in their Army uniforms down Shawano Street on the North Side, under a sign welcoming the Fighting Kelly Brothers home. Danny, keeping stride in street clothes, looks up at them admiringly.

Advertise with us

“The stories I always heard was that he always wanted to be like his brothers,” Ms. Donovan said of her Uncle Danny. “He wanted to join the service.”

The timeline is short. In 1950, his brother Chuck signed the papers that enabled Danny to enlist at the age of 17. In May, he went to boot camp at Fort Knox in Kentucky. Six months later, he was flown to California, then Japan. A day later he was in Korea, a corporal in the 9th Infantry Regiment. A week later, he was gone, missing in action in the massive Battle of the Chongchon River in North Korea.

The family was devastated, but it was Chuck who took it the hardest, blaming himself.

"Chuck always felt bad that he had signed for Danny," brother Edward Kelly said in an interview before his death in 2012. "He always felt if he hadn't signed for Danny, he would have been alive today."

Danny’s loss and the death of Chuck Kelly’s young wife soon after, helped turn the rest of Chuck Kelly’s life into an aimless wandering. He died in a Pittsburgh VA hospital in 1985.

Advertise with us

“Those couple things weighed heavy on him,” Ms. Gentile said of her famous uncle. “I remember one of the remarks he said was, ‘It was easier being in the service.’”

What happened to Danny wasn’t known. The Army said he was captured on Nov. 26, 1950, a bitterly cold day that was a turning point in the Korean War.

“Basically, [Gen. Douglas] MacArthur had the idea of pushing into North Korea,” said military historian Donald M. Goldstein, the former director of the Matthew B. Ridgway Center for International Security Studies at the University of Pittsburgh. “It kind of seesawed, with the North pushing in and them pushing them back, and then things ... He didn’t count on the Chinese coming in. It was pretty bad.”

They marched into a trap. Danny Kelly and the 9th Infantry Regiment, 2nd Infantry Division, were driving toward the Yalu River when tens of thousands of Chinese soldiers relentlessly poured over the hilly terrain for a ferocious fight that continued through the night and into the next morning.

The Army’s casualties were estimated at more than 600. The Chinese took more than 2,000 soldiers prisoners.

Advertise with us

“Nobody really knows how many died or were captured there,” Mr. Goldstein said. “We still have MIA from the Korean War and we never got the bodies back. And Kelly was one of those guys.”

After the war, a soldier who survived a POW camp told authorities Danny Kelly had died March 31, 1951, four months after being captured. The cause of death is not known.

Sgt. First Class Kristen Duus, with the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency in Arlington, Va., said there are 7,727 soldiers still missing from the Korean War. But in 2002, a joint U.S.-Korean recovery team found hundreds of human remains in an American POW camp known as Death Valley near Kujang, North Korea.

The DPAA reached out to two of the remaining Kelly brothers for DNA samples in 2012. Testing in Honolulu in March 2017 identified some of the remains as those of Danny Kelly.

“I was in total shock,” Ms. Gentile said of the April phone call telling her of the confirmation.

Advertise with us

The return of the remains has brought back memories of the Kelly brothers, all of whom have died.

“I don’t see how one family could give any more than what they gave,” said Daniel Kelly, 59, of Butler, who was named after his uncle.

As the oldest surviving relative, Ms. Gentile has been busy making funeral arrangements with the members of the next generations. She and her cousin will meet the plane Monday afternoon. Then a memorial service will be held Thursday at Sperling Funeral Home in Wexford.

“All the brothers that had children will have a child there,” Ms. Gentile said. “They’re excited. ... . I have not talked to my cousins this much in years as I have in the last three months. Everybody’s been ecstatic and they’ve all been very helpful.”

Afterward, Cpl. Daniel Francis Kelly will be buried with military honors at National Cemetery of the Alleghenies in Bridgeville. The cross will be inscribed: “Beloved Brother. Never Forgotten.”

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.