A lawyer for Leon Ford, shot five times by a Pittsburgh police officer in 2012, said Tuesday that Mr. Ford is now a paraplegic because police jumped to conclusions in mistaking him for a known gang member with a similar name.
"This case is about poor police work," Fred Rabner told a federal court jury. "Poor police work got Leon in that wheelchair."
His comments marked the opening statements in Mr. Ford's civil rights case against Pittsburgh police officers David Derbish and Andrew Miller.
Lawyers for the officers will make their opening statements Wednesday.
Mr. Ford, 24, sued the city and several officers and supervisors in 2013 on grounds of excessive force and other civil rights violations.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen Kelly, who is hearing the case, threw out some of his claims and dismissed the city, several police supervisors and another officer as defendants.
Read More
But she allowed the case to proceed against Officer Derbish, who fired the shots, and Officer Miller, who Mr. Ford said assaulted him when he refused to get out of his car after a traffic stop in Highland Park on Nov. 11, 2012,
Officer Derbish had asked for summary judgment on Ford's excessive force claim, but the judge said a jury will have to decide as to whether that force was reasonable because so many facts are in dispute.
Among those facts are whether Mr. Ford was a threat or the officers thought he was; whether there was a bulge in his sweatpants that Officer Derbish said he thought was a gun; and whether Mr. Ford was trying to flee when his car began rolling forward.
Mr. Rabner said the officers mistook his client for a gang member, Lamont Ford, after pulling his car over. He said Mr. Ford, 19 at the time, protested that they had the wrong man, but that the officers became convinced that he was Lamont. The situation grew tense, Mr. Rabner said, as they accused Mr. Ford of being Lamont and demanded he get out of the car to look at a picture of Lamont.
Mr. Rabner said Leon was afraid and refused.
"He's scared to death," Mr. Rabner said.
Officer Miller then grabbed him and tried to pull him from the car, Mr. Rabner said.
Officer Derbish, who had been called to the scene by Officer Miller, then jumped into the passenger side of the car, which began moving. Mr. Rabner said neither his client nor Officer Derbish can say exactly what happened in the car or why it moved, but Officer Derbish fired five times into Mr. Ford's chest from point-blank range as the car traveled about 20 yards and crashed into some steps.
Another officer, Michael Kosko, pulled the bleeding Mr. Ford from the car and handcuffed him on the ground.
As Mr. Ford was lying there, Mr. Rabner said, he heard one of the cops swear and heard all of them yelling "Where's the guns, where's the drugs?"
Mr. Rabner said the officers were desperate to find guns or drugs to justify the shooting. He said the police have maintained that the shooting was reasonable considering the circumstances.
"There is nothing about what these officers did that was reasonable," Mr. Rabner said.
A county jury convicted Mr. Ford of traffic violations in 2014 but acquitted him of aggravated assault in connection with the traffic stop. The jury deadlocked on the remaining charges, including reckless endangerment and resisting arrest. The district attorney's office chose not to retry Mr. Ford.
The federal trial is expected to last three weeks.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.