Most peo­ple prob­a­bly didn’t no­tice, but Hur­ri­cane Har­vey hit Pitts­burgh over the week­end.

The rem­nants of the storm that dumped more than 50 inches of rain in parts of south­east­ern Texas couldn’t even man­age to squeeze out a quar­ter-inch of wa­ter over south­west­ern Penn­syl­va­nia.

That may come as a re­lief to those who re­mem­ber the dev­as­tat­ing im­pact on the re­gion from the left­overs of Hur­ri­cane Ivan in 2004 or Hur­ri­cane Agnes in 1972.

The city’s riv­ers crested at 31 feet dur­ing Hur­ri­cane Ivan — 6 feet above the 25-foot flood stage — from about 6 inches of rain. Dur­ing Hur­ri­cane Agnes, they crested at 35.82 feet, nearly 11 feet above flood stage. That was caused by 4 to 8 inches of rain over sev­eral days.

Advertise with us

“Now imag­ine if we had re­ceived 30 inches of rain over four days,” said Jon Nese, a pro­fes­sor in Penn State Univer­sity’s me­te­o­rol­ogy de­part­ment. “I’m not a hy­drol­o­gist … but my gut tells me if that much rain fell across Pitts­burgh in four days, it would far ex­ceed any­thing that has ever been ex­pe­ri­enced in the city.”

While the ab­surd, and un­of­fi­cial, rain to­tal of 51.88 inches was recorded in Texas dur­ing Hur­ri­cane Har­vey, Mr. Nese said, Har­ris County, where Hous­ton is lo­cated, re­ceived an av­er­age of 35 inches from the storm. Har­ris County was one of the ar­eas hit hard­est by the storm and con­tin­ues to deal with flood­ing as well as a hu­man­i­tar­ian cri­sis.

That kind of rain­fall would cause un­think­able dam­age in Pitts­burgh, though it’s vir­tu­ally im­pos­sible to get a storm of that mag­ni­tude here.

The St. Patrick’s Day flood in 1936 was the worst flood in the city’s recorded his­tory. The riv­ers that day crested at 46 feet — 21 feet above flood stage — from 8 to 10 inches of rain com­bined with snow melt. Ac­cord­ing to the Na­tional Weather Ser­vice, up to 15 feet of wa­ter cov­ered the Golden Tri­an­gle.

It’s hard to say what 50 inches of rain would look like in Pitts­burgh. Flood to­tals gen­er­ated from a cer­tain amount of rain the area has re­ceived in the past can­not be sim­ply mul­ti­plied be­cause the wa­ter would not rise evenly. The wa­ter would flow far­ther up­stream and into val­leys that ha­ven’t been flooded be­fore, or, at least, not flooded as badly.

Advertise with us

“That has to do with our to­pog­ra­phy and el­e­va­tion,” said Joe Palko, a se­nior hy­drol­o­gist with the Na­tional Weather Ser­vice in Pitts­burgh. “Around here, you have hills and val­leys and [wa­ter] just con­cen­trates.”

Water from the storm in Texas rose rel­a­tively slowly be­cause the land there is fairly flat. In Pitts­burgh, wa­ter would be fun­neled to low-ly­ing ar­eas and cause dan­ger­ous flash flood­ing.

If a storm dumped 50 inches of rain here, the Hill Dis­trict, Pol­ish Hill and higher por­tions of the North Side could re­main above flood­wa­ters, Mr. Palko said, but Down­town would be in trou­ble.

Mr. Palko es­ti­mated that even af­ter the wa­ter spreads out, the Golden Tri­an­gle would be cov­ered by 25 feet of wa­ter and the riv­ers would crest at 60 feet.

Ac­cord­ing to statis­tics from the weather ser­vice, the foun­tain at Point State Park would be en­vel­oped quickly by wa­ter, as would roads and rail­roads along the pe­rim­e­ter of Down­town, the North Shore and South Side. Point State Park would be sub­merged to the over­pass, fol­lowed by the play­ing sur­faces at Heinz Field and PNC Park. The floor level of Rivers Ca­sino would soon be un­der­wa­ter, and wa­ter would con­tinue to rise. Down­town would flood all the way to PPG Paints Arena.

Advertise with us

The wa­ter would make its way to places that reg­u­larly flood, such as Etna, Car­ne­gie and down the Ohio River to Beaver, and up the Mo­non­ga­hela River to Eliz­a­beth. Water and sew­age treat­ment plants along the river would be in­un­dated. In­dus­try and trans­por­ta­tion in and along the riv­ers would be im­pacted.

The 16 flood con­trol res­er­voirs in and around Pitts­burgh can hold only about 3½ to 6 inches of run­off, said Megan Got­tlieb, a hy­drau­lic en­gi­neer with the U.S. Army Corps of Engi­neers. She ex­plained that if a storm is pre­dicted to drop more than 6 inches of rain, the res­er­voirs likely would be set to spill­way flow, mean­ing wa­ter is re­leased down­stream.

“Spill­way flow in our res­er­voirs isn’t nec­es­sar­ily a bad thing,” Ms. Got­tlieb said. “It’s what the dam is de­signed to do so that it’s not over top, but it’s un­con­trolled flow.”

That’s what would hap­pen if a storm brought more than 6 inches of rain, but what about 50 inches? It would be un­prece­dented and dif­fi­cult to spec­u­late on, she said.

“I can­not give you a high-wa­ter mark that 50 inches would do, but it would most cer­tainly crip­ple us,” Ms. Got­tlieb said.

Advertise with us

Of course, that much wa­ter would crip­ple any city.

Mr. Nese put it this way: The en­tire sur­face of Penn­syl­va­nia would be cov­ered by about 32 inches of wa­ter if that much rain fell across the state.

“There are es­ti­mates that 25 tril­lion gal­lons of wa­ter fell in south­east Texas and Lou­i­si­ana — 25 tril­lion gal­lons,” he said. “I cal­cu­late, just as a lo­cal bench­mark, that is 20 per­cent of the vol­ume of Lake Erie. To es­sen­tially take 20 per­cent of the wa­ter out of Lake Erie and then drop it as rain on south­east Texas and Lou­i­si­ana. That is what hap­pened, which to me is pretty re­mark­able.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.