Halfway through a three-hour City Council meeting, 14 bangs of the gavel couldn’t silence Darlene Harris.
And Bruce Kraus wasn’t giving up.
“I am going to have the councilwoman removed in about 30 seconds,” Mr. Kraus, the Pittsburgh council president, threatened his longtime adversary. He had tried thrice to gavel down her commentary, arguing that Mrs. Harris veered — once more — too far from the topic at hand.
“OK, you do that. We can go to court, too, Mr. Kraus,” Mrs. Harris charged back, reprising her constant refusal to address him as president. She said “it’s only me that you ever interrupt.”
Both eventually calmed themselves. Mr. Kraus didn’t throw her out. Mrs. Harris didn’t sue him.
The discussion July 12 had been about money and staffing, but the real subject tilted again to “Darlene and Bruce”: the personal and political soap opera that has electrified otherwise-sedate council meetings for several years. Even their sharpest insults have become so commonplace — he asked if she had gas; she called him the worst Pittsburgh council president ever — that the terse barbs rarely draw attention beyond Grant Street gossip.
Argument over each others support of Donald Trump
Few months pass without the jabs between Mr. Kraus, who represents southern neighborhoods in District 3, and Mrs. Harris, a former council president who speaks for the north in District 1. While colleagues insist the feud doesn’t undermine the work of the nine-member body, some observers privately say the fights embarrass a city hall that’s straining to stretch budgets, lure residents, restore failed infrastructure and help house the poor.
“I think this dynamic has played out more publicly in council meetings than in other settings,” Councilman Dan Gilman said. Mrs. Harris and Mr. Kraus don’t have the only strained relationship on council, but theirs takes a public face because Mr. Kraus is president, Mr. Gilman said.
Where Mr. Kraus brings a citywide approach to governing, Mr. Gilman said, Mrs. Harris “has a strong sense of protecting her neighborhoods first.”
Their differences ripple in waves from there. Each has accused the other of supporting President Donald Trump’s policies — heresy on the all-Democrat council. Farther back, in 2014, Mr. Kraus fined Mrs. Harris $20 after saying she flung a gavel at him. She could have challenged the punishment in court, she told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last week.
“Look how he beats the gavel. You don’t have to beat the gavel like that,” Mrs. Harris said in her office in the City-County Building. She said “he doesn’t even know how to bang a gavel correctly.”
Mr. Kraus declined to speak for this story. Outside council meetings, Mrs. Harris said, they don’t speak.
Speaking too far off the subject at hand
It wasn’t always like this. Shortly after Mr. Kraus took office in 2008, the pair had lunch together every day, Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said. Others remembered Mrs. Harris counseling him when he was a newcomer.
“At one time, it was something everyone wanted to emulate,” Mrs. Kail-Smith said of their bond.
She speculated that hurt feelings from that broken alliance may spill into their conflicts now.
“For me, it’s difficult because I get along with everyone on council,” said Mrs. Kail-Smith, who is council president pro tempore. She said that “once you get past everything you see on camera, you know there’s good people” on council.
“We’d like to see all of our members working together in the best interests of our constituents and City Council,” Mrs. Kail-Smith said.
Precisely how the Harris-Kraus rapport went from lunch to tongue lashes is tougher to decipher. Several council insiders were hesitant to delve into details, at least for publication. Mrs. Harris said Mr. Kraus changed after Bill Peduto won election as mayor, turning into a “yes man” and “Kool-Aid drinker” for the Peduto administration. She claimed Mr. Kraus “doesn’t try to bring council together.”
“I don't think you've ever seen me be disrespectful [to him] first — ever,” Mrs. Harris said. “It's only when he tries to shut me up.”
Mr. Gilman said the meeting flare-ups happen when someone deviates from standard procedure for the gatherings. He didn’t name names, but his observation echoes complaints that Mr. Kraus has levied against Mrs. Harris. In a gathering last month, Mr. Kraus declared that he was “still the chair of this meeting” and needed respect as he and Mrs. Harris spoke over each other.
“No matter whether you’re in disagreement, I believe there are certain protocols that need to be followed,” said Mr. Gilman, who was an aide to Mr. Peduto when the mayor was a councilman.
Mr. Gilman said Mr. Kraus concerns himself with “the priorities of each member,” takes a vested interest in national issues and represents the most diverse district in the city. Others cast Mr. Kraus as a persistent consensus-builder.
Still, days before Mr. Peduto assumed the mayor’s seat in January 2014, Mrs. Harris voted against Mr. Kraus to succeed her as council president. Only Councilman Ricky Burgess joined her to oppose Mr. Kraus, who won a second two-year term as president in January 2016.
That time, only Mrs. Harris dissented.
Councilwoman Darlene Harris swears
Mr. Kraus “feels that it’s his duty to represent all council members as the president and has tried to heal that divide, but still it festers,” said Mr. Peduto, who defeated Mrs. Harris in the Democratic mayoral primary race this year. He thinks the Harris-Kraus hostility springs from tension around the council presidency, he said.
“She had lost the votes, and Councilman Kraus was coming in as the new president,” Mr. Peduto said. “She refused to leave the council president’s office. To this day, she’s still in it. Bruce gave that up. He just wanted to try to get harmony on the council. It just hasn’t worked.”
Mrs. Harris offered a different account about the president’s office suite, which is roughly twice as large as any other council member’s office on fifth floor of the City-County Building. She said Mr. Kraus declined the bigger space when she offered it.
For older political observers, such disagreements evoke memories of City Council’s past, including the late councilwoman Michelle Madoff, who invited a colleague to kiss her rear end under the landmark Kaufmann’s clock, Downtown. She served from 1978 to 1993.
Sitting council members tend not to be so combative, often backing Mr. Peduto’s policies and requests.
Mrs. Harris excepted.
“The business of council is that you may have nine Democrats. But when you have one party, you really have no party,” Mr. Peduto said. “And different opinions should be expected. It’s just best if it’s done with civility.”
Council President Bruce Kraus and Councilwoman Darlene Harris argue
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.
Videos are courtesy of City Channel Pittsburgh; http://pittsburghpa.gov/innovation-performance/city-channel-schedule; http://pittsburgh.granicus.com/ViewPublisher.php?view_id=2





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.