On Friday, Pittsburgh’s Commission on Human Relations hosted a public hearing to discuss religious and ethnic intimidation. The conversation centered on how Pittsburgh could welcome those who arrive as documented immigrants, as refugees or as undocumented immigrants.
The hearing offered an opportunity for leaders representing refugee organizations, Islamic organizations and many others came to offer their perspectives and recommendations for city policy. Community members also came to speak directly to city commissioners to voice concerns and offer positive feedback.
“We need these individuals to step forward and provide information in a forum that is safe and where the information will be taken seriously,” Carlos Torres, the Executive Director of the city’s Council on Human Relations. “We understand that it can sometimes be a little intimidating for individuals to reach out to a government agency for assistance, … so that’s why we are holding a public hearing.”
At the panel discussion called “Discrimination Based on Religion,” Muslim youth leader Israa Barakat spoke of the increase in discrimination she has experienced since the 2016 presidential election. Born in Iraq, she grew up in Syria and immigrated to the United States five years ago with her mother. Her father and brother have stayed behind in Syria, still unable to get visas to come to the United States.
“People who don’t like Muslims are much more confident now. A girl in my high school told me, ‘Your father and brother should stay in Syria and you should go back,’” Ms. Barakat said. “They can do whatever they want.”
Ms. Barakat is not alone in feeling an increase in acts of discrimination about her religion.
“We have seen an increase in the number of instances where a person's religion is perceived to be Muslim,” Mr. Torres said. “That is alarming. Something that begins as a verbal altercation can lead to something more serious very quickly.”
Many other members in the room came representing the undocumented community in Pittsburgh, which is mostly Latino. A central concern of the undocumented Latino community is the degree to which Pittsburgh will resist Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the main federal bureau involved in finding and detaining undocumented immigrants.
“The fear they live in is very real. ICE is conducting raids and picking up people at a much higher rate in the state of Pennsylvania than in any other state,” Monica Ruiz, a community organizer said. “Some are afraid to leave their homes to go work, to take their children to school, or to go to church to worship. That is not the type of the city that I would like to live in.”
Cities that refuse to comply with ICE officers to the fullest extent of the law are known as “sanctuary cities.” Pittsburgh has not declared itself a sanctuary city, although the City Council will host a hearing about the designation later this month after a petition circulated by the Pittsburgh Sanctuary City Coalition received about 60 signatures.
Betty Cruz, the project coordinator of the immigrant welcoming organization All for All and a member of the panel on sanctuary cities described a city ready to support immigrants.
“The good, if you can point to some good that has happened since the election is people coming forward and saying, ‘What can I do? How can I help?’” she said. “We need that outpouring of support because there are still people and institutions who are making decisions that are not inclusive of all Pittsburghers, period."
She paused, reflecting.
"It sounds nice to say that we want to be welcoming or that we want to offer a sanctuary or that we want to be more inclusive," she said. "It's not so much what we call it as much as it is what we are actually doing to make sure that the policies that are passed are doing what they said they would do."
Amelia Nierenberg: 412-263-1370; anierenberg@post-gazette.com; @ajnierenberg. Adam Smeltz contributed reporting: asmeltz@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.