The Philadelphia Inquirer, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and other media outlets have petitioned Montgomery County Judge Steven T. O’Neill to release the names of the jurors in the recent trial of Bill Cosby. The jurors — all from Allegheny County — were discharged Saturday when they were unable to reach a unanimous decision after more than 50 hours of deliberation in the case.
Jurors’ names are routinely made public at the close of trials, but in this case, Judge O’Neill kept them under seal.
Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin R. Steele said he would retry the case, which seemed to give the judge pause about releasing the jurors’ names. Judge O’Neill told the panel members they should keep their deliberations confidential. Not only did he say they had no obligation to speak to reporters or grant interviews, but he also warned that doing so could potentially affect the outcome of Mr. Cosby’s retrial.
On Saturday, a lawyer for Philadelphia Media Network, owner of the Inquirer, Daily News, and Philly.com, sent the judge a letter seeking the immediate release of the names. In it, Eli Segal of Pepper Hamilton LLP said the information was of “extraordinary public importance” and the news outlets had a First Amendment right to it.
Without such disclosure, Mr. Segal wrote, “the ‘value of openness itself’ — a fundamental pillar of our judicial system in this country — is threatened.’ ”
Documents:
Read More
- Commonwealth’s memorandum of law to respect the privacy of those who have served on a jury by not releasing the jurors’ names
- Media’s motion to intervene and for access to discharged jurors’ names
- Media’s reply brief in support of intervenors’ motion for access to juror names
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette joined Philadelphia Media Network in seeking a release of the names. The Associated Press, ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, Hearst, the New York Times, and The Washington Post also joined the motion.
Judge O’Neill gave Mr. Steele until Monday to decide if the government would oppose the media request, and Mr. Steele did.
“If the press saturates the nationwide media market with stories about jury deliberations, including juror opinions about the evidence, it may make the parties’ ability to select a fair an impartial jury more difficult,” Mr. Steele wrote in a motion Monday.
Mr. Steele also said, “If the press descend upon the discharged jurors, this publicity onslaught may have a chilling effect on future jurors on this remarkably high-profile case.”
One man claiming to be an alternate juror has already reached out to media to talk about the experience.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.