In the end, the decision to choose the most extensive alternatives for Port Authority’s proposed Bus Rapid Transit system and run it through Oakland using Forbes and Fifth avenues came down to two things: cost and safety.

The cost between stopping the electric-vehicle system in Oakland or extending it on three wings to Squirrel Hill and Highland Park on existing streets and Wilkinsburg via the Martin Luther King Jr. East Busway is so minimal — about $30 million — that it makes sense to build the whole system, said Justin Miller, principal transportation planner for the city. The estimated cost of the project is $233 million.

The Port Authority, Pittsburgh and its Urban Redevelopment Authority and Allegheny County are working together to develop the project. They expect to have a funding request ready to submit to the Federal Transit Administration by the end of September.

Selecting a path that sends outbound BRT vehicles on Forbes Avenue through Oakland and inbound on Fifth Avenue was a matter of dollars and sense, Mr. Miller said.

Advertise with us

It would be more expensive to put all BRT traffic on Fifth Avenue and build bike lanes on Forbes, Mr. Miller said, than it would be to have BRT on both streets and adapt the existing contra-flow bus lane on Fifth Avenue for bike lanes only. It also would be safer for pedestrians on Fifth Avenue if buses didn’t use the contraflow lane.

Mr. Miller said both decisions became clear through dozens of community meetings and more than 2,500 submitted comments on the project. The Oakland business community in particular was concerned about the option of taking buses off Forbes.

“The results were pretty clear that people wanted the extensions and wanted vehicles on both streets,” Mr. Miller said. “Not only are the bike lanes a good fit on Fifth Avenue, it eliminates the danger of the contra-flow bus lane.

“The branches provided a way to extend the system at a marginal cost.”

The system will use dedicated lanes to carry BRT vehicles between Downtown and Oakland. The Wilkinsburg branch will use the busway, and the Highland Park and Squirrel Hill routes will use existing roads with separate queuing lanes and smart traffic signals at intersections to move the transit vehicles through more quickly.

Advertise with us

“What they picked is what we supported,” said Eric Boerer, advocacy director for Bike Pittsburgh.

“We do have some concerns about Forbes because we know some bikers will still use it. Forbes feels like it should be a neighborhood street but it’s treated more like a highway, so we hope they can do something about that.”

By choosing those extensions rather than limiting the system to the Downtown-Oakland corridor, the system will link 24 neighborhoods, many of them disadvantaged areas such as Homewood.

In addition, a major part of the project involves rebuilding much of the infrastructure on Forbes and Fifth as the avenues pass through the Uptown neighborhood: new streets curb to curb, new sewers, and bioswales between the sidewalks and street. Through a series of community meetings, residents strongly supported the improvements even if they resulted in reducing non-BRT traffic to one lane and eliminating one lane of parking, said project manager Joe Wingenfeld.

“Our people think the positives outweigh the tradeoffs,” Mr. Wingenfeld said. “Now, this is a very car-centric area. [These changes] would make all kinds of transportation accommodated.”

Advertise with us

Planners still have several major areas to deal with before the project is submitted to the Federal Transit Administration by the end of September. In addition to application requirements such as an environmental impact statement and preliminary engineering, they must choose the location of stations; where to park Access vehicles that serve the elderly and people with disabilities; how other motorists make turns across BRT lanes; and whether to charge riders a fee for transferring from buses to the BRT system in Oakland.

Accommodating Access has been a particularly difficult problem that planners had expected to resolve by now.

“That is one of the things that will continue to be discussed,” said Port Authority spokesman Adam Brandolph. “There certainly is a solution to this problem, but we have to keep talking to people and decide which way is the best way to go.”

The agency expects to schedule additional public meetings on the project in June.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.