Suicides, treatment of pregnant inmates and health care staffing shortages have all been problems at the Allegheny County Jail in recent years. But how involved the county’s Jail Oversight Board should be in fixing them is a matter of debate.
The issue of the role of the board — and how robust its level of oversight should be — came to a head at a recent meeting.
Board member Terri Klein, noting the mission of the board is to ensure discipline and safekeeping of prisoners and proper management of the jail, inquired as to a recent lengthy lockdown that had been reported by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
In the Feb. 15 newspaper brief, Warden Orlando Harper confirmed the nearly week-long lockdown but would not say why or specify the degree of restrictions on the jail’s inmates, citing “security reasons.”
Board member Chelsa Wagner, who also is the Allegheny County controller, said she believed it would be appropriate for the board to learn more about what happened, “based on the purview of this board.”
Judge David Cashman, the oversight board’s president, said it was not up to the board to direct policy at the jail.
Read More
“We’re not here to tell the warden, ‘You have to take X number of prisoners and put them in solitary.’ That’s not our function. Our function is … oversight. Look at potential problems, make recommendations, oversight. We don’t set policy,” Judge Cashman said.
Ms. Wagner said she believed board members are entitled to basic information, and that overseeing inmate health and welfare is a broad responsibility.
In addition to Ms. Klein, Ms. Wagner and Judge Cashman, the nine-member board comprises Common Please Judge Dwayne Woodruff, county Sheriff Bill Mullen, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, county council President John DeFazio, M. Gayle Moss and Earlene Coleman.
Board members meet once a month and are not paid. Some elected officials opt to send a representative and do not personally attend the meetings. The three citizen members are appointed by Mr. Fitzgerald. Judges are appointed by President Judge Jeffrey Manning.
Board members can also vote on spending money from the jail's welfare fund, which is funded by inmate commissary sales.
Both Ms. Klein and Ms. Wagner have pushed for more vigorous oversight in other areas as well. In October, they conducted an unannounced inspection of the Downtown lockup, which board members are permitted to do, but which had not been done in recent years. The report they submitted cited concerns with health care-related staffing, which has been a persistent problem.
The statute establishing the board calls for two unannounced inspections per year. It also says the board’s powers and duties “shall include the operation and maintenance of the prison … the oversight of the health and safekeeping of inmates,” and the confirmation of the warden.
The board is also charged with ensuring “living conditions within the prison … are healthful and otherwise adequate” and that it “shall investigate allegations of inadequate prison conditions and improper practices occurring within the prison.”
That board members are not adequately informed of problems at the jail is not a new complaint. In 2011, then-board member Jim Burn complained that neither county council nor the oversight board had been informed of an escape attempt.
Michele Deitch, a senior lecturer at Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs at the University of Texas and an expert on corrections oversight, said, generally speaking, a good oversight structure would allow for an independent individual who can visit the jail and speak with any staff member, inmate, or inmate’s family member.
That person, who could be a contractor or a county employee who does not report to jail officials, should be able to issue reports that are publicly available, she said.
Marion Damick, 91, is a volunteer “official visitor” for the Pennsylvania Prison Society. She often visits the facility and speaks to inmates. She speaks every month at the oversight board during the public comment period, though the board often does not act on her suggestions.
“Anytime the government takes on the awesome responsibility of depriving a person of their freedom and exercising total control over them, there needs to be some independent way of ensuring that person’s safety and health. That is important both from the standpoint of the inmate and it benefits the county. When there are safety issues, it can result in liability, lawsuits and protracted legal issues,” Ms. Deitch said.
Whenever the American Civil Liberties Union becomes aware of a problem in the jail, that advocacy group either speaks to the county executive or, if need be, files a lawsuit, said Vic Walczak, legal director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania.
“It’s not a body that we have looked to for getting relief on civil rights problems,” he said of the board.
The ACLU has an ongoing lawsuit over the treatment of pregnant inmates at the facility and has had previous lawsuits over issues at the jail.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.