Pittsburgh was to steel what Detroit was to cars, and huge numbers of manufacturing jobs were evaporating in the region along with the collapse of the steel industry when liver transplant pioneer Thomas Starzl arrived here on New Year’s Eve 1980.

His high-profile work in the region drew patients and funding that would help spur a subsequent boom in Pittsburgh’s medicine and higher education economy, which has since evolved into a startup business economy powered by the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University. While Dr. Starzl was turning science fiction into medical miracles in Presbyterian Hospital’s operating rooms in Oakland, some observers believe he was also helping fuel the city’s economic rebirth.

“The rebirth began in the ashes of our steel industry,” said Marlee Myers, a Squirrel Hill native who has had a front row seat to the city’s economic transformation as legal counsel to Free Markets Inc., Fore Systems Inc. and other successful city startup companies. “Tom Starzl is emblematic of what Pitt university research and CMU research have done to transform the region.”

Dr. Starzl, who died at age 90 on March 4 at his home in Oakland, will forever be linked to organ transplantation. But his work in Pittsburgh and the revenue it generated also allowed hospital network UPMC to recruit other talented doctors and researchers, and eventually grow into a $14 billion enterprise with an international reach.

Advertise with us

“Transplantation, in reality, made a lot of money for the institutions,” said Ngoc Thai, director of the Center for Abdominal Transplantation at Allegheny Health Network who began working with Dr. Starzl in 1990. “When they made all that money, it gave them money to recruit researchers, to elevate the whole enterprise.

“Tom Starzl created hepatology; Tom Starzl elevated anesthesia; Tom Starzl created a lot of research.”

Read More

Pittsburgh had the only active liver transplant program in the country when Dr. Starzl performed the first liver transplant here in 1981, which grew quickly to 636 transplants by 1986.

Ironically, money meant little to Dr. Starzl, Dr. Thai said. A 1992 New York Times story pegged Dr. Starzl’s salary at $300,000, much less than many of his peers. Pitt spokesman Joe Miksch declined comment on the subject.

“He never cared about the money,” his former colleague said. “He cared about the patient and the science.”

Advertise with us

Even as Dr. Starzl gradually increased the length of survival for patients after organ transplants with new anti-rejection drugs, the Pittsburgh economy was in a free fall.

Between 1980 and 1986, the number of manufacturing jobs in the region fell by 43 percent, a loss of over 115,500 jobs, according to research done by Sabina Detrick, co-director of the University Center for Social and Urban Research at Pitt. Half the job losses were in steel.

At the height of the crisis, in January 1983, Pittsburgh’s unemployment rate hit 18.2 percent — about twice the national average — with 212,400 people out of work, according to a study by Pitt economist Christopher Briem.

But something else was happening between 1980 and 1986: educational services rose 85 percent to 27,626 jobs, while health service jobs grew 21 percent to 84,684. The combined job growth essentially replaced losses in manufacturing, according to Ms. Detrick’s research.

Many of the new jobs didn’t pay as well as the ones lost, but the old jobs weren’t coming back and the shift to a service economy was happening nationwide.

Advertise with us

The trend is continuing, with health care-social assistance jobs accounting for almost one-third of the projected job growth nationwide through 2022, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Locally, growth in the sector proved durable: the number of health care jobs increased by 61 percent to 127,662 and educational service jobs rose 29 percent to 39,058 between 1986 and 1994, according to the Pitt research.

[Read more: Local officials, leaders react to Thomas Starzl's death]

Pittsburgh didn’t create these trends, but was at the forefront of a nationwide movement that was discovering the economic engine of medicine and higher education.

In that sense, Dr. Starzl’s contributions ultimately prompted academic medical centers around the country to set up their own transplant programs and eroded the number of the operations done in Pittsburgh — 504 liver transplants in 1988 compared to just 120 at UPMC’s Pittsburgh hospitals in 2016 as the number of centers proliferated.

Advertise with us

Dr. Starzl retired from clinical and surgical practice in 1991, 10 years after his first liver transplant in Pittsburgh.

Organ transplants were far more lucrative for hospitals in the early years than today because of reimbursement caps that have since been imposed by insurers, according to Roger Evans, president and CEO of United Network for the Recruitment of Transplantation Professionals, a physician recruitment outfit in Rochester, Minn.

A hospital’s margin for organ transplants was about 25 percent in the early years, when such operations were still a novelty, which was “quite impressive” compared to other service lines, he said.

“The value in what Tom Starzl did when he arrived in Pittsburgh was very significant,” Mr. Evans said. “You also increase referrals, which opens the door to other kinds of interventions that a hospital offers.”

In the public’s eye, organ transplants buff the image of other hospital service lines, said Gene Monaco, principal at Southpointe-based health care consultant MediTechnix Inc.

Advertise with us

“It’s the halo product,” he said about transplants. “It gives you street cred.”

“Tom Starzl is emblematic of what Pitt university research and CMU research have done to transform the region.” — Marlee Myers, legal counsel to Free Markets Inc., Fore Systems Inc. and other successful city startup companies

At a time in the 1980s when the city’s image was shriveling along with its economy, Dr. Starzl’s accomplishments “put Pittsburgh on the map for something other than being the smokiest, dirtiest, most declining industrial city,” said Timothy Parks, who in 1983 became the first executive director of what was then called the High Tech Council, later renamed the Pittsburgh Technology Council. “He shifted the way Pittsburgh was viewed.

“During that period, there was a lot of study as to what could we do to turn around this economic landscape.”

A little luck also helped in Pittsburgh’s rebirth.

Advertise with us

In 1980, the Bayh-Dole Act was signed into law, allowing public universities for the first time to commercialize products that were discovered using federal research dollars. That opened the door to university spinout companies and a new source of revenue.

Another boost came five years later when travel company Rand McNally named Pittsburgh the most livable city.

“Eds and meds has been absolutely central to the story of Pittsburgh in the 21st century,” said the 66-year-old Ms. Myers, a University of Pittsburgh trustee and past UPMC board member, whose father didn’t graduate from high school and whose grandfather arrived in Pittsburgh from Ukraine as a door-to-door peddler.

“Alcoa, Rockwell, Westinghouse, Gulf Oil — those days are gone. We could’ve gone the way of Detroit, but we didn’t. We have a very diversified economy now and we’re poised for a lot of future growth.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699