An Allegheny County judge on Thursday urged city and private attorneys to work through a legal dispute over the Penn Plaza apartment complex in East Liberty, continuing the matter for a status conference and conciliation March 3.
“I think they’re talking, and I want them to continue to do that,” Judge John McVay Jr. said in court. “And they agreed to do that.”
Pittsburgh city officials filed a complaint Wednesday seeking an injunction to stop any demolition activity at the Penn Plaza site and to ensure “a decent, sanitary building” for remaining tenants there, as well as adequate heat and electricity.
LG Realty Advisors is redeveloping the site for a controversial Whole Foods Market and new residential use. The company and affiliate Pennley Park South reached a memorandum of understanding with the city last year to provide moving allowances, relocation assistance and later move-out dates after notices alerted residents that they had to leave within 90 days.
In the complaint Wednesday, the city claimed the developer engaged in demolition activity before a March 31 deadline for all residents to be out of the building and had failed to provide proper heating, all in violation of the memorandum of understanding. It also stated Pennley Park cut down 10 trees in violation of that agreement.
Jonathan Kamin, attorney for LG Realty and Pennley Park, said Wednesday that the developer followed the agreement and “will continue to do so.”
Read More
The matter landed in motions court Thursday for scheduled oral arguments. Mr. Kamin met privately with city attorneys including solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge in the City-County Building, Downtown, before both sides conferred with Judge McVay.
After about 40 minutes in Judge McVay’s chambers, they emerged with a court order that he signed. The order says the parties agree to a “standstill” until the status conference March 3. Judge McVay also encouraged them to refrain from commenting in the news media.
Mr. Kamin declined to comment afterward. Judge McVay declined to elaborate on the “standstill” terminology. But Mayor Bill Peduto’s top aide, Kevin Acklin, said the administration interpreted the language as a ban on any demolition at Penn Plaza before the status conference.
Mr. Acklin declined to address details of the court matter. About 20 residents out of more than 200 remain in the apartment complex. Of those remaining, 14 are still looking for housing, Mr. Peduto said.
On Wednesday, the administration asked 16 developers in the East Liberty area to help place those Pittsburghers. By Thursday afternoon, Mr. Peduto’s office had spoken with at least four or five of the developers, Mr. Acklin said.
He said the administration is planning a meeting next week to discuss developers’ available housing inventory.
“It really does require everyone working together on this last 14,” Mr. Peduto said.
Staff writers Mark Belko and Kate Giammarise contributed. Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.