There are dozens of surveys that come out weekly trying to show which cities are the best or worst place to live, or have the best nightlife or are home to the best sports fans.
It is hard to tag any real relevance to many of them.
But one survey that came out this week ranking Pittsburgh as the seventh best city — not metro area — for people who want to live an “active lifestyle” seems to reflect some reality on the ground, not only because of current efforts, but decisions made more than a century ago by city planners.
“I’ve been here two years now and I’m blown away by the number of parks here and how easy it is to be active here,” said Mary Kathryn Poole, director of Let’s Move Pittsburgh, the five-year-old Michelle Obama-inspired organization focused on children’s health and fitness. “So, I’m not surprised by the ranking. For kids and adults it’s not hard to be active here.”
The survey was put together by the personal finance company, WalletHub, which does similar surveys monthly to try to drive online traffic to its website.
With help from 10 academic experts, Wallethub evaluated the 100 largest cities in the country and looked at 30 fitness-related categories, such as the average cost to go bowling ($3.99 here, ranking the city 20th), number of sporting goods stores per 100,000 people (47.4, ranking fourth) and the share of physically inactive residents (20.7 percent, ranking 52nd).
But what put the city near the top of the list were a series of metrics that looked at the number of baseball diamonds, swimming pools, basketball hoops, tennis courts, public golf courts, skate parks and bike rental facilities per 100,000 residents or 1 million residents (depending on the category).
In all of these types of metrics, Pittsburgh was easily ranked in the top half, and ranked No. 1 in the number of baseball diamonds and swimming pools.
“Remember, we have 150 to 170 parks in the city,” city Parks Director Jim Griffin said Friday. “But they were built for a city of 600,000 people and now we have about 330,000 people and our facilities ratios look great.”
Another factor that plays into that, though, is the city’s topography, that long ago led neighborhoods that might only be a quarter mile apart as the crow flies, but several miles by road because of a valley between them, to demand they have their own pool or baseball diamond.
“We’ve got rec centers in Polish Hill and in the Hill District,” Mr. Griffin said. “They’re less than a quarter-mile out from each other, but a lot farther to drive from one to the other.”
Jill Gonzalez, an analyst with Wallethub who helped craft the survey, said having “so many no-cost fitness options really helped Pittsburgh’s rankings.”
That refers to three metrics that looked at the number of hiking, walking and running routes in the city, all of which ranked in the top third in the survey.
Mike Carroll, director of events for Bike Pittsburgh for the last five years, said the city ranked well in those categories, as well as biking-related categories, thanks to a variety of local nonprofit and governmental efforts over the last two decades.
“In the early to mid-’90s Biking Magazine had us ranked as one of the worst cities in the country for biking,” he noted. “Now they have us in the top 20. So we’ve come a long way.”
As far as the city has come, there is work to do.
The metrics on baseball diamonds, for example, can be a little deceiving, said Brian Vogel, president of the Brookline Little League, one of the largest such leagues around.
There are a lot of baseball fields in the city, but: “Are they playable fields?” he asks. “With all the cuts in the budget they’ve kind of let the fields go. We have to maintain our fields ourselves.”
Mr. Griffin, the parks director, said his budget is strained every year trying to maintain and keep all of the city’s 18 outdoor pools open, let alone making other improvements — all of them more than worth the effort he said.
“We serve 95 percent of the public in any year,” he notes. “But [the parks department is] less than 1 percent of the city budget. We could do amazing things with 2 percent or even 1½ percent.”
“Look, I’m not VisitPittsburgh or the chamber of commerce, but, I can tell Pittsburgh has this incredible park system that goes back 150 years and was well planned,” he said. “But we need to make sure we provide funding and support and get people to at least come visit and use our parks because people inherently understand their value.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.