Roman Catholics are as polarized as any other group during this election campaign.

Bishop David Zubik of Pittsburgh has seen that firsthand.

The leader of the region’s largest religious population used much of his column space in the most recent edition of the Pittsburgh Catholic newspaper in describing various reasons people give him for why Catholics should not vote for one or the other candidate. Some cite Democrat Hillary Clinton’s support for abortion rights and gay marriage, others the multiple accusations that Republican Donald Trump mistreated women or his calls for walling off Mexico to prevent illegal immigration.

Some cited religious liberty. Bishop Zubik was the lead plaintiff in a religious-liberty Supreme Court case against the current Democratic administration — involving the Obamacare contraception mandate as it applied to faith-based charities and schools. But others cite religious-liberty concerns in Mr. Trump’s opposition of Muslims entering the country, including those fleeing Syria’s warfare.

Advertise with us

And while WikiLeaks has released old emails among Clinton campaign staffers that some saw as condescending to conservative Catholics, Mr. Trump this year also described as “disgraceful” Pope Francis’ statement that Mr. Trump’s idea of walling off immigrants was not Christian.

In past elections, voters typically weighed the positive and negative aspects for each candidate, Bishop Zubik said.

“Unfortunately, this election you compare the negatives with the negatives,” he said, adding that he and others feel without a political home in this election.

“You can’t vote for something that goes against your faith,” he said, including on the issues of abortion and religious liberty.

Yet as the grandson of Slovak and Polish immigrants, he said he’s very concerned about “the direction the Republican Party would be taking on the issue of immigration.”

Advertise with us

He urged Catholics to study the issues and make the best decision they can on Tuesday.

Bishop Zubik said he’s hoping for more unity on the day before. Today, he’s asking all Catholic churches to open their doors for prayer before the Blessed Sacrament, or communion host, which Catholics believe is the presence of Jesus Christ.

Catholics are a crucial voting population — but hardly a bloc — composing close to one-third of likely voters in the swing state of Pennsylvania, according to Franklin & Marshall College Poll results.

A Franklin & Marshall poll in September found Catholics evenly divided on the presidential race, while an October poll put Ms. Clinton ahead among Catholics by 16 points. But that was before her numbers nationally began deflating amid the latest revelations about an FBI investigation into her emails.

The Franklin & Marshall poll director, Terry Madonna, said he believes many Catholics in southwestern Pennsylvania will be supporting Mr. Trump, not so much over moral issues but because they come from the blue-collar heritage in which Mr. Trump’s economic positions resonate.

Advertise with us

In its voter guide, distributed in Catholic churches and other settings, the Pennsylvania Catholic Conference gives samplings of the presidential candidates’ positions on various issues while laying strong emphasis on the right to life, including opposition to abortion and euthanasia.

The guide describes Mr. Trump’s self-described evolution from a “pro-choice” to a “pro-life” position and Ms. Clinton’s support for abortion rights and removing the ban on federal funding for abortion.

The guide also describes Mr. Trump’s plan to crack down on “illegal aliens” and Ms. Clinton’s support for giving immigrants who entered illegally a “pathway to full and equal citizenship.” It does not cover Mr. Trump’s calls to bar Muslims entering the country but does cite his opposition to taking in Syrian refugees.

Amy Hill, spokeswoman for the conference, said the voter guide was limited by space but aims to “illustrate the kinds of things Catholics need to be thinking about and praying about,” and encourages them to seek out more information.

Some Catholics, like some conservative evangelicals, are supporting Mr. Trump because of his promise to appoint conservative Supreme Court justices who they believe will restrict abortion and side with them on religious-liberty cases.

Advertise with us

An Illinois bishop, Thomas Paprocki, said abortion is the “defining moral issue” of modern times, cited Ms. Clinton’s support for legal abortion and said that “people who vote for pro-abortion candidates are cooperators in evil.” He encouraged Catholics to discuss vote-related questions with a priest at confession.

Sister Mary Traupman, a Catholic religious sister from Ross who is supporting Ms. Clinton, said the church’s pro-life teachings cover the whole range of life, not just birth. She said that also means finding ways to reduce warfare, gun violence and the death penalty and to promote better jobs and health care. She said women often have abortions due to poverty, and the Democrats’ support for a living wage, she said, would be a crucial way to reduce them.

“We cannot be single-issue voters; we have to look at the whole,” she said.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.