Port Authority doesn’t run into this one too often: Residents on a North Side cul-de-sac are upset that the authority re-established bus service on their street last month after a six-year absence.

They say the buses are noisy, too heavy for part of the complex built on a landfill and dangerous given the five ball fields, swimming pool and playground at the Brighton Woods Road entrance. Some residents of the 80 homes there have complained to Port Authority officials since the bus trips began Sept. 25 but have gotten nowhere so far.

“All of a sudden, we’ve got a lot of buses coming through here.” said Holly McCarthy, a board member of the New Allegheny Homeowners Association who has lived on the street about 4½ years. “It’s very loud, it’s constant and it’s very smelly.”

Port Authority spokesman Adam Brandolph said a “kind of happy coincidence” allowed the agency to restore bus service on Brighton Woods Road.

Advertise with us

The neighborhood had rush-hour service from the mid-1980s until Port Authority cutbacks eliminated some routes in 2010, including the 16D route that served Brighton Woods during weekday rush hours. The 17 Shadeland and 18 Manchester routes served Benton Avenue, which provides access to Brighton Woods.

Changes as part of the agency’s twice-a-year route adjustments in September reduced the Manchester route to run a shorter distance and only on weekdays and expanded Shadeland. Shadeland now runs more often, but half of its weekday trips and all of its weekend runs end at Brighton Woods, which has a convenient place for drivers to stop between trips and turn around on the circle at the end of the street.

As a result, buses pass through the neighborhood 26 times on weekdays, 30 times on Saturdays and 28 times on Sundays.

Mr. Brandolph said he disputes that the buses smell bad — the agency uses only clean diesel fuel — and said he doesn’t understand concerns about layovers of 20 minutes maximum.

“I’m not sure why [residents are complaining] because now they have public transit,” he said.

Advertise with us

Residents say that’s not the issue. They were satisfied with walking to the end of the street to catch a bus and say they never see anyone getting on in the neighborhood.

Rita Stone said she moved to the neighborhood in 2010, after bus service was discontinued. She’s not happy it returned.

“Had they been running and I knew they were running, I probably wouldn’t have bought my house,” she said. “[The buses] are too close and there’s no need.”

Another neighbor, Sandy Lazzara, has lived there 20 years and her husband occasionally used the bus before 2010. Now, she said, she fears the neighborhood is too busy in the summer to accommodate bus traffic.

“In the summer, I can’t fathom a bus coming onto our street,” she said. “It’s wall to wall with cars from people going to ball games and swimming. I’m afraid a child is going to get hit.”

Advertise with us

Another issue for the neighborhood is ownership of the street. The City of Pittsburgh says the developer hasn’t filed all of the paperwork for the city to take ownership, Councilwoman Darlene Harris said, which means it remains a private street and neighbors have had to pay more than $20,000 for two waterline breaks.

If it is a private street, Port Authority shouldn’t use it and Mrs. Harris has asked the agency to stop. If it is a public street, the city could order buses off of it due to the concern of residents that heavy buses will damage pavement installed on landfill.

Mr. Brandolph said the Port Authority will monitor bus use and determine whether it should change the route. Residents say the authority dismisses their concerns.

“They give us fantastic lip service,” Ms. Lazzara said. “There are options we have given them [to route the buses elsewhere], but they aren’t listening.”

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.