After meeting this morning with Mayor Bill Peduto, the president of Pittsburgh's police union told reporters that Chief Cameron McLay "needs to reevaluate the direction he's taking the department in..."
Officer Robert Swartzwelder, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1, gathered behind closed doors with the mayor and Zone 1 Cmdr. Christopher Ragland to discuss labor issues and the police bureau's unresolved contract situation.
One thing that did not come up, according to Officer Swartzwelder: the union's recent straw no-confidence vote in Chief McLay.
The union president said nearly 277 active FOP members out of 291 who cast votes in an online poll -- nearly 38 percent of the FOP's 729 members -- expressed no confidence in Chief McLay. A formal vote is anticipated Thursday.
"The examination of the no-confidence vote is this: that the police don't feel he has their best interests at hand," Officer Swartzwelder said after meeting with the mayor.
The chief's "first and foremost responsibility" is to lead the department forward, Officer Swartzwelder said.
Read More
"They don't think he's doing that based on a lot of issues. In other words: forced overtime, forced response to secondary employment details, violations of different provisions of the contract. So this isn't without merit," he added.
Officer Swartzwelder declined to say how he voted.
He clarified that there are more than 100 officers in training who cannot vote because they are technically not in the FOP yet.
Although any vote by the FOP at Thursday’s scheduled meeting would be only symbolic, the mere fact that the union is querying its members about how they feel about the chief reflects a high level of frustration and friction in the bureau.
The straw poll means that "the regular, everyday, working police officer doesn't have confidence in the direction that the chief has taken the police department in," Officer Swartzwelder said.
Chief McLay issued a statement Monday night saying he anticipated resistance from officers.
"Any time a police chief attempts significant changes to an organization's approach to policing, cultural resistance and pushback are normal and inevitable," the chief said. "I fully expected such resistance when I came here. Facing confidence votes is simply one of the realities faced by major city police chiefs today."
Mayor Bill Peduto said in a separate statement that he continues to support the chief.
"I continue to have full confidence in Chief McLay and in his efforts to improve the bureau to better serve the residents of Pittsburgh," Mr. Peduto said. "Reform is never easy in any organization, and we will continue to work with the men and women of the Police Bureau to strengthen morale."
Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to the mayor, sent an email last month to the bureau's command staff saying in part that he "was personally disappointed to learn that an online no confidence vote regarding Chief McLay was posted on the FOP website."
Mr. Acklin also said he had met with Chief McLay and public safety director Wendell Hissrich "to clarify respective roles and responsibilities, so that officers are clear that while the Public Safety Director oversees financial, disciplinary and promotion matters, the Chief and Command Staff are in full control of the operations of the bureau."
A no-confidence vote is not unprecedented in Pittsburgh. In 1998, the FOP voted no confidence in then-Chief Robert W. McNeilly Jr. His boss, Mayor Tom Murphy, supported the beleaguered chief.
Tensions between officers and Chief McLay have long run high, for a variety of reasons.
A few months after his arrival, Chief McLay was photographed Dec. 31, 2014, holding a sign that said, “I resolve to challenge racism @ work. # end white silence.”
Union leaders accused Chief McLay of violating the bureau’s social media policy and of being “hypocritical” for disciplining two officers who violated it. The chief later sent an email to officers apologizing “if any of my PBP family was offended,” adding “I saw no indictment of police or anyone else in this sign.”
More recently, Officer Swartzwelder criticized the chief's appearance in uniform at the Democratic National Convention in July, saying he thought it violated bureau regulations and local laws requiring officers to remain politically neutral.
A draft report by the independent Citizen Police Review Board took a similar stance, but investigators with the city's Office of Municipal Investigations disagreed and Democratic Mayor Bill Peduto decided the chief would face no discipline.
In talking to reporters Tuesday, Officer Swartzwelder noted that he was not in uniform and said the city's ruling on the chief's convention appearance left him "confused."
"I don't know whether or not I can wear a uniform and speak," Officer Swartzwelder said. "You notice I'm in a suit and tie today because I'm not permitted to speak on labor issues in uniform. So if you're going to speak at a political event, you can do so, but make sure you're not in uniform."
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Adam Smeltz, 412-263-2625 or on Twitter @asmeltz. Andrew Goldstein contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.