About one third of Pittsburgh’s unionized police officers have indicated they have no confidence in Chief Cameron McLay in an online poll conducted ahead of a formal vote anticipated for later this week.

Sgt. Jim Glick, vice president of the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1, said Monday night that 291 members out of about 850 in the union voted in the poll. Of those, 277 — or just under 33 percent — said they had no confidence in Chief McLay.

Although any vote by the FOP at Thursday’s scheduled meeting would be only symbolic, the mere fact that the union is querying its members about how they feel about the chief reflects a high level of frustration and friction in the bureau.

Chief McLay issued a statement Monday night saying he anticipated resistance from officers.

Advertise with us

"Any time a police chief attempts significant changes to an organization's approach to policing, cultural resistance and pushback are normal and inevitable," the chief said. "I fully expected such resistance when I came here. Facing confidence votes is simply one of the realities faced by major city police chiefs today."

Mayor Bill Peduto said in a separate statement that he continues to support the chief.

"I continue to have full confidence in Chief McLay and in his efforts to improve the bureau to better serve the residents of Pittsburgh," Mr. Peduto said. "Reform is never easy in any organization, and we will continue to work with the men and women of the Police Bureau to strengthen morale."

Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to the mayor, sent an email last month to the bureau's command staff saying in part that he "was personally disappointed to learn that an online no confidence vote regarding Chief McLay was posted on the FOP website."

Mr. Acklin also said he had met with Chief McLay and public safety director Wendell Hissrich "to clarify respective roles and responsibilities, so that officers are clear that while the Public Safety Director oversees financial, disciplinary and promotion matters, the Chief and Command Staff are in full control of the operations of the bureau."

Advertise with us

Tensions between officers and Chief McLay have long run high, for a variety of reasons.

A few months after his arrival, Chief McLay was photographed Dec. 31, 2014 holding a sign that said, “I resolve to challenge racism @ work. # end white silence.”

Union leaders accused Chief McLay of violating the bureau’s social media policy and of being “hypocritical” for disciplining two officers who violated it. The chief later sent an email to officers apologizing “if any of my PBP family was offended,” adding “I saw no indictment of police or anyone else in this sign.”

More recently, Officer Robert Swartzwelder, president of the FOP, criticized the chief's appearance at the Democratic National Convention in July, saying he thought it violated bureau regulations and local laws requiring officers to remain politically neutral.

A draft report by the independent Citizen Police Review Board took a similar stance, but investigators with the city's Office of Municipal Investigations disagreed and Democratic Mayor Bill Peduto decided the chief would face no discipline.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1352 or on Twitter @angolds.