An arbitration award received Monday by the city of Pittsburgh and the Fraternal Order of Police would increase officers’ scheduling rights, but means stagnant paychecks for a force that already feels underpaid.

Police get raises of 1 percent this year and 2 percent in each of the next two years under the award. But starting next year, they’ll pay 15 percent of their health insurance charges, up from around 9 percent now, which could negate the raise.

That creates little incentive for officers to stay with the city, rather than going to easier and more lucrative suburban departments, said Officer Robert Swartzwelder, president of FOP Lodge 1. “If they just decide, ‘you know what, we’re sick of this,’ and just walk, you’ll have huge gaps in [police] coverage. Huge,” he said.

Mayor Bill Peduto, though, called the award “a fair — and legally required — contract in which neither side got everything it wanted.” He said it is consistent with the recovery plan under Act 47, the law for distressed municipalities that caps contract awards and has governed city finances since 2004.

Advertise with us

His spokesman, Tim McNulty, noted that the city expects to have brought on 130 new officers by year’s end. "So there's great interest in being a Pittsburgh police officer, as it's one of the best police departments in the entire country,” he said.

The award awaits only the signature of a neutral arbitrator, who is expected to sign it this week. The union’s arbitrator dissented from the award. It takes effect immediately, although the union in an appeal to the state Supreme Court might ask for a stay.

The administration emphasized improvements in officer control over scheduling. Under the award, police can bid for new locations and shifts annually. Currently, only one quarter of the officers — the most experienced — can bid for new assignments.

The award also includes a pilot program under which officers could opt for schedules of four 10-hour days, and restricts the circumstances under which they can be called in on their off days.

Officer Swartzwelder, though, said city officers’ base pay is already 20 to 22 percent below that received by their counterparts in surrounding municipalities, and that gap could rise to 30 percent by the contract’s end in 2018.

Advertise with us

Now, first-year officers earn base pay of $42,973, the most experienced officers $64,149, sergeants $69,981 and lieutenants $79,778.

The FOP president said that 325 officers who have more than 20 years of service — enough to qualify for full pensions — could opt to leave the bureau, as could officers who aren’t yet vested in the pension plan. The city has around 850 uniformed members, including some in training.

Pensions, he said, continue to be calculated based on base pay without regard to overtime, whereas some other city retirees get retirement benefits sweetened based on the extra hours they worked in their final years. And overtime only kicks in after police have worked 40 hours in a week — not necessarily when they are required to work beyond eight hours in a day.

“I can assure all our officers that the mayor hears their concerns about this contract,” said police Chief Cameron McLay in a press release. “Now that arbitration is over, we are proceeding to tackle other open issues that I know officers care about, relating to secondary employment and overtime.”

The union’s core argument during the 18-month contract fight has been that Act 47 should no longer apply, because the city is financially healthy. Now it has 30 days to appeal an award that rejected that argument.

Advertise with us

Officers have been working under the terms of a contract that expired at the end of 2014. The new award gives officers no raise for 2015.

The city and the union are separately wrangling in court appeals over the residency requirement that demands that bureau employees live in Pittsburgh.

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.