A former Pittsburgh police sergeant charged federally with using excessive force against an intoxicated man outside Heinz Field and writing a false report about it says the falsification count should be dismissed because he didn’t know at the time that he would be facing a federal investigation.

But the government countered in court papers Friday that the federal law in question applies to both ongoing investigations and any investigation that may take place in the future.

The unusual debate marks the start of what promises to be a contentious legal battle between Stephen Matakovich and the U.S. Attorney’s office.

Mr. Matakovich is under indictment on charges of deprivation of civil rights and falsification of a record in connection with his arrest of Gabriel Depres in November.

Advertise with us

His lawyer, Tina Miller, a former assistant U.S. attorney, is arguing in court filings that count two should be thrown out, saying it is “unconstitutionally vague because it failed to provide him with reasonable notice of what conduct was prohibited following his encounter with Mr. Despres.”

She says her client couldn’t have intended to impede the federal investigation when, at the time of the incident, “there was no federal investigation” and he couldn’t have known he would become the subject of an FBI probe.

She also said that because federal use-of-force cases against police officers are fairly rare, Mr. Matakovich could not have contemplated that he would be the subject of a federal case.

In a response filed Friday, federal prosecutors say that argument has no merit.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung said it is “absurd to argue that the defendant, a trained, seasoned police sergeant, is unaware that the use of excessive force could be investigated as a federal crime” in light of the history of other high-profile federal cases across the U.S.

Advertise with us

She also said that if Mr. Matakovich’s argument were to succeed, it could apply to anyone who commits a federal crime and covers it up by falsifying a record.

She said an “ordinary person (and the defendant in particular, an experienced police sergeant) can easily understand” that such conduct is barred by the federal statute.

The former officer initially was suspended with pay in mid-December following the incident at Heinz Field during the WPIAL football playoffs. He was fired in March.

Stadium security camera footage showed Mr. Matakovich pushing Mr. Despres with two hands and striking him several times. A mug shot taken of Mr. Despres, who was arrested following the incident and spent the night in the Allegheny County Jail, showed him with a swollen and bruised nose.

Mr. Matakovich said at the time that Mr. Depres “lunged toward me” and “punched me in my chest” while the sergeant tried to arrest him. Mr. Despres, 20, of South Park, pleaded guilty in June to summary charges of trespass and public drunkenness.

Mr. Matakovich also faces state charges of official oppression and simple assault in relation to the incident.