The Pittsburgh Public Schools website lists a number of acts it considers to be plagiarism.

They include turning in someone else’s work as your own; copying words or ideas from someone else without giving credit; failing to put a quote in quotation marks; and giving incorrect information about the source of a quotation.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has reported in recent weeks that Anthony Hamlet, who was hired in May to be the new superintendent of the city’s public schools, copied nearly word for word the “educational philosophy” on his resume from a 2015 Washington Post editorial.

This, as well as other revelations about facts stated on Mr. Hamlet’s resume, has galvanized some to demand that the school board find a different leader for the district. While Mr. Hamlet’s fate in Pittsburgh remains unclear, it’s clear to experts that the words on his resume were plagiarized.

Advertise with us

Just how severe a case of plagiarism it is, however, is up for discussion.

“Yes, it’s plagiarism, but … not all plagiarisms are created equal,” said Jonathan Bailey, a copyright and plagiarism consultant who authors the website PlagiarismToday. “When they plagiarize an entire novel versus plagiarizing just a passage, it’s a big difference.”

Mr. Bailey defines plagiarism as “the using of another person’s words or ideas and not providing proper attribution or directly claiming them as your own.” But he says there is some gray area when determining whether something is plagiarism.

In academia, particularly in the syllabuses of high school and college classes, plagiarism is sometimes more specifically defined. For example, a 1998 syllabus for a University of Pittsburgh architecture and urbanism of the Pittsburgh region class taught by Franklin Toker states: “Plagiarism is here defined as the use of six words in a row without a quotation mark and/​or clear indication of their origin.”

But instances of plagiarism committed by students are often innocent mistakes due to incorrect citations or lack of knowledge about what plagiarism actually is, some educators say.

Advertise with us

“One of the things that I’ve come to realize is that there’s different understanding of plagiarism,” said Adriana Helbig, assistant dean of academic integrity at Pitt. “The rules of how to actually cite your own work change because [of] our social media and the ways that people produce information changes.”

But ignorance can’t always be an excuse.

Just last week, Ms. Helbig said, she had two cases in which students were accused of plagiarism. In one, the student didn’t properly cite a tweet. In the other, a student bought an essay online and submitted it for a course.

“So do these two students then get the same punishment, which is basically an ‘F’ in the course, which is the university policy?” Ms. Helbig said. “The tweet cite, I count that as a technicality, so there’s no way that I wanted to enforce the full extent [of school policy] for that student. The student that bought the paper online, that’s a whole other situation.”

In certain cases of plagiarism, real consequences go beyond the classroom.

Advertise with us

Copyright law can become a factor when dealing with plagiarism, but Mr. Bailey said he does not believe The Washington Post would have a case against Mr. Hamlet.

“The amount that was taken was just so small; it was only a couple sentences,” he said. “The portion copied probably doesn’t qualify for copyright protection by itself. It’s likely that case would not go anywhere.”

Regardless of whether Mr. Hamlet could find himself in any legal trouble, an ethical question of his actions still remains.

“If you’re in a position of leadership, an example that you’re setting needs to be exemplary, especially if they’re going into the education system,” Ms. Helbig said. “You are the person that is creating the reality for these students before they enter the real world, and you’re teaching them how to engage with the real world.”

Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, agreed that educators must set high standards, but no one, not even teachers, is right all the time.

Advertise with us

“We hold ourselves out as having very high ethical behavior, but all of us have made mistakes,” she said.

Ms. Weingarten said that after a speech she gave years ago, she was informed that she used the exact phraseology that someone else had earlier.

“As soon as it was brought to my attention, I apologized about it,” she said.

“At the end of the day, no one condones plagiarism, no one condones doing things that are not honest, and we want everyone to have a lot of integrity in what they do,” Ms. Weingarten said.

Then citing what has been reported about Mr. Hamlet’s work as an administrator for the Palm Beach County (Fla.) public schools, she said he “is someone who actually works with teachers and parents, had a good collaborative relationship, understands that poverty matters and children’s well-being matters. And that’s part of the reason why I assume he got a unanimous vote out of the Pittsburgh school board.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.