Nearly two years after Mayor Bill Peduto renovated his wing of the century-old City-County Building, his administration and the city controller still don’t agree on how much it cost, though both agree that updates were needed.

The mayor’s chief of staff, Kevin Acklin, called the offices “hodge-podge” as he walked through them last week, pointing to some repainted white with royal blue or sage accents and others with new carpeting in a greenish hue called “nest egg.”

The administration tried to be judicious with what Mr. Acklin said was “largely a paint job.”

Offices in particularly bad shape were repainted and got new carpet. Some needed asbestos remediation or ceiling repairs because of water and sewage leaks.

Advertise with us

“It was just like any other office that hadn’t been redone in a while. Some of the offices were fine. Some had a lot of work that needed to be done. It’s a 100-year-old office. A lot of people have worked here,” mayoral spokesman Timothy McNulty said.

In Mr. Peduto’s corner office on the fifth floor, curtains were replaced by blinds that easily open to a view of Grant Street below.

Four cast plaster chandeliers from 1918 were “severely cracked around their structural bands and could easily fall from the ceiling,” according to a proposal for repairs. Typhoon Lighting in Regent Square restored the fixtures for about $12,000, invoices show. Mr. Acklin said he didn’t know what caused the damage, but one hung askew and he found part of another in a drawer.

Bright white paint was used to cover tan walls in Mr. Peduto’s office, and brown carpeting was ripped up to expose hardwood. In the adjoining secretaries’ office, marble found below carpeting also was refurbished.

Two to three city carpenters and two painters worked in the mayor’s corner office, but not in a full-time capacity, Mr. Acklin said. Sometimes workers were called elsewhere during their shifts, he said.

Advertise with us

The brown carpet that was in the mayor’s office still spills into the adjacent conference room, where community meetings and news conferences take place. Royal blue-painted wall panels there and in Mr. Acklin’s office match those on the top half of a long, straight hallway that connects about two dozen offices.

“This administration is about collaboration, and does this office look collaborative?” Mr. Acklin said, waving to a long row of “last-century” offices, some doors ajar, others closed.

But midway down that hall is a noticeably different space.

The lunch and meeting room’s furniture, kitchenette, lighting and rug, worth about $10,000, were donated to the city by IKEA. Modern white track lighting hangs above bright green and yellow chairs. Art owned by Mr. Peduto adorns the walls.

The lounge, Mr. Acklin said, is reminiscent of companies, such as Google, that rely on talent.

Advertise with us

That IKEA donation and the labor cost of the fifth-floor renovations were targets of an audit released this month by Controller Michael Lamb’s office.

The city doesn’t have a good way to track such donations, auditors said. Mr. Acklin said the Office of Management and Budget is drafting recommendations to document such donations.

According to the audit, the Department of Public Works cited material costs of $43,477.05, and invoices show that about half of that went to flooring and heating and air-conditioning work.

Public works also told auditors that city carpenters, electricians, HVAC technicians, laborers, painters and truck drivers spent 7,736 hours — equivalent to 322 days and 8 hours — on the project.

The in-house labor came at no additional cost to the city, Mr. Peduto’s administration holds.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Lamb’s office says those hours cost the city $239,679.03. Public works did not put a price tag on the workers’ time, so auditors arrived at that figure by multiplying the number of hours worked by 2014 budgeted hourly rates.

“This is an old building, and it needs a lot of work,” Mr. Lamb said. “There’s enough work to cover that kind of money. It’s a matter of priorities” and being transparent about labor costs, he said.

Critics also blasted the administration last year amid various departments’ office renovations to the tune of a half-million dollars while conditions at some city public works, police and fire facilities deteriorated.

But Mr. Acklin said auditors’ figure is a “physical impossibility,” and that the department didn’t have a way to properly track hours. He said the costs of city office renovations are a “drop in the bucket,” representing less than 10 percent of the city’s investment in facilities in 2014 and 2015.

Lexi Belculfine: lbelculfine@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1878. Twitter: @LexiBelc.