Police officers had to make a quick decision after they followed a white-tailed deer from Third Avenue through Downtown streets to the parking lot of the old Post-Gazette building around noon Sunday.

A fast-moving wild animal in a busy urban area is in danger, and is a danger to others.

Animal Care and Control personnel were on hand, and officers had contacted the state Game Commission and Pittsburgh Zoo by the time they had the deer cornered in the lot bounded by Boulevard of the Allies, Commonwealth Place and Fort Pitt Boulevard.

“Someone got on the [radio] and asked, ‘Have we exhausted all our resources?’” said public safety spokeswoman Sonya Toler. “The answer was yes. In any situation, the ranking officer on the scene has to assess the threat to public safety and make a decision about how to handle it. In this case, the deer was separated from [its group] and obviously distressed. In a few seconds that one deer could have caused a lot of damage to property and people. It could have made Father’s Day a very tragic day.”

Advertise with us

A wildlife control officer arrived after the deer had been dispatched by police.

“We wouldn’t second-guess their decision,” said Brian Singer, law enforcement supervisor for the Game Commission’s southwest district. “The officer had to assess the threat to public safety and determine the best way to remove it.

Mr. Singer said that with a panic-stricken deer threatening to bolt into city traffic, tranquilize and transfer was not an option. And not just because city police do not have tranquilizer guns.

“When you dart a deer, that often causes it to run blindly, and that’s specifically what they wanted to avoid to keep it off the streets,” Mr. Singer said. “Plus, deer suffer a high rate of ‘capture myopathy’ — they die in transfer at a high rate. We’re the state wildlife management agency and we almost never transfer deer.”

The deer was a male.. Ms. Toler, an experienced hunter, said judging from a description of its bulk it was probably at least 2 years old. Deer with vehicle injuries and wildlife behaving strangely are occasionally dispatched by police citing public safety concerns, but a panicked deer on urban streets is rare, Ms. Toler said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Singer said it is extremely unlikely the deer wandered in from the suburbs. This deer lived Downtown.

“Deer have no problem cohabiting with humans, even in cities,” Mr. Singer said. “Any time you have that many people and wildlife in the same place you’ll have conflicts.”

About 100 years of wildlife management studies have shown that in unnatural urban habitats with a virtually unlimited food supply, does develop near-maximum reproductive carrying capacity. With no predators and no hunting, white-tailed deer populations can double every 2 to 2½ years, outgrowing their living space, resulting in more deer-human conflicts.

“There are a lot of deer that live Downtown,” Mr. Singer said. “Almost every day we get calls about human conflicts with deer all over the area.”

They’ve been seen just a few blocks from Third Avenue in the steep, woody sliver between the Allegheny County Jail and the base of the Uptown Bluff — the narrow strip parallels the Parkway East and Three Rivers Heritage Trail all the way to the Birmingham Bridge, where it expands into the second-growth forests of Terrace Village. Farther up the Monongahela River, overpopulated deer affect all animal habitats in Schenley and Frick parks.

Advertise with us

On the Allegheny River side, deer thrive in the Polish Hill woodland below Frank Curto Park. Volunteer archers from the nonprofit Whitetail Management Associates organize controlled hunts in parts of Allegheny Cemetery, as they do in all of the Allegheny County parks.

The city doesn’t specifically track deer-human conflicts, but deer roadkill pickups on city-maintained roads rose from 209 in 2012 to 330 in 2014.

In 2010, Citiparks requested a study by the state Department of Agriculture that documented problematic deer density in the city’s parks. Parks and Recreation staff proposed initiating a wildlife management plan. There was no response from Pittsburgh City Council, and the issue has not been brought up again, according to mayoral spokesman Tim McNulty.

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.