A jury on Monday began deliberating a federal civil rights case pitting a Pittsburgh police officer against the city and former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl over her claim that she was improperly placed on paid leave because she complained about favors done for one of the mayor's cronies.
Officer Tonya Ford says the 2013 move was in retaliation for her protests against parking variances granted Robert Gigliotti, a valet service owner close to Mr. Ravenstahl and former police Chief Nate Harper.
The city says she was placed on leave because of her ties to Harper at a time when he was under investigation by the FBI for stealing public money from a police credit union account.
In closing arguments this afternoon, Officer Ford's lawyer, Sam Cordes, said his client was singled out for punishment because of her protests. But he said that Public Safety Director Mike Huss knew he couldn't fire her legally, so he placed her on leave as a "shot across the bow" to anyone who complained about the mayor's "political friends."
Both Mr. Huss and Mr. Ravenstahl said during the weeklong trial that Mr. Gigliotti and parking issues were not on their "radar" until Officer Ford and three others were placed on leave in February 2013. Mr. Huss said he did not even know who Mr. Gigliotti was until he saw his picture in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
Mr. Cordes said those claims are not credible, considering that others in the city administration and police department knew of Mr. Gigliotti's influence.
Read More
"He is lying to you," Mr. Cordes said of Mr. Huss.
Mr. Cordes said the same of Mr. Ravenstahl.
Mike Kennedy, assistant city solicitor, said Officer Ford has not shown that anyone retaliated against her.
"I believe the evidence is so thin as to not exist," he said.
He said she had been complaining to other officers about the parking variances for years but the city took no action against her until the 2013 federal investigation of Harper and the police department.
He said Mr. Huss had information at the time from the FBI and others that Officer Ford was tied to a police credit union account from which Harper pilfered money and that he properly placed her on leave while federal authorities conducted their investigation.
He also pointed out that Officer Ford kept her full pay and benefits during the leave.
"How is that punishment?" he asked, saying Mr. Huss could have fired her, suspended her without pay or placed her in an undesirable shift or job within the department had he wanted to retaliate against her.
He told the jury that the suit is an attempt to punish the city for "doing the right thing" in removing someone whom officials believed may have been involved in a federal crime. Officer Ford was cleared of wrongdoing in relation to Harper.
"There was no retaliation here," Mr. Kennedy said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.