The second civil rights trial pitting Pittsburgh police Officer Tonya Ford against the city over her three-year suspension began Tuesday just like the first one, with her testifying that she objected to parking variances that were handed out to valet service owner Robert Gigliotti, a political ally of then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and former police Chief Nate Harper.
Officer Ford claims in a federal lawsuit that she was suspended because of those objections.
But the city says she was placed on leave because she was close to Harper, who was under federal investigation in 2013 and ultimately went to prison.
The first trial in May ended in a mistrial after Officer Ford’s lawyer, Sam Cordes, got sick.
But he was back in court Tuesday as the case resumed with a new jury. The trial is expected to last a week.
Officer Ford says the city retaliated against her when she complained about the number of Downtown variances being issued to Mr. Gigliotti’s business, Tri State Valet.
She said that when she was out enforcing variances for valet operators, she and other officers were told not to bother Tri State even though the company was taking up entire streets with parked cars in violation of its variance.
“We would receive a call from Chief Harper ordering us to leave him alone,” she said.
She said sometimes those calls came from Assistant Chief George Trosky or from Mr. Gigliotti himself.
She also said when she was placed on leave without explanation by the public safety director, Mike Huss, Mr. Ravenstahl was waiting outside in the hall.
She testified that she later received a call from Lt. Matt Gauntner, her office mate, who said he heard the mayor say she was suspended because of her complaints.
In his opening statement, assistant city solicitor Mike Kennedy said Mr. Huss suspended Officer Ford because the FBI was investigating the chief and city administration and she was part of a group of Harper confidants.
“Parking variances were nowhere to be seen on the horizon,” he told the jury. “Michael Huss had no idea that this was a concern of hers.”
As he did during the first trial, he said there is no evidence to show that Officer Ford ever formally complained about the parking variances.
The trial will continue today before U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.