Since they overpowered a mentally ill man with a knife who had taken a 16-year-old girl as a human shield on March 25, 2013, in the East Liberty Target store, Michael Turner, Roland Smith and Jobe Wright have been hailed as heroes by everyone from the girl’s parents to the Pittsburgh police.

But Target Corp. doesn’t see them that way.

“We’re contending their actions created this situation” that led to the girl being stabbed and seriously injured, contended Tom Birris, an attorney representing Target in his opening statements Wednesday in a civil case in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. “They had an opportunity to call 911, but they didn’t.”

The lawsuit being heard in Judge Alan Hertzberg’s courtroom is expected to last two weeks, and is actually a consolidation of three intertwined cases.

Advertise with us

The case began when the family of the girl, Allison Meadows, now 19, sued Target, alleging that the store failed to provide adequate security to prevent Leon Walls, 44, from attacking her.

Target countersued Walls, who has since been convicted but found mentally ill in a criminal case, as well as the three men who rescued Ms. Meadows. Two of the three rescuers, Mr. Smith and Mr. Wright, then countersued Target, alleging they were also injured in the melee that occurred at the store as they tried to stop Mr. Walls.

The whole incident began about 5:30 p.m. on a Monday in 2013 when Walls stabbed Mr. Wright for no reason a couple of blocks away from the Target store while Mr. Wright was talking with Mr. Taylor and Mr. Smith.

Walls ran into the Target store, where Mr. Smith finally located him. First Mr. Smith, and later Mr. Taylor, Mr. Wright, and a fourth man not involved in the civil case, Tyrique Walker, confronted him in the store. As they pursued Walls, he grabbed an unaware Ms. Meadows as she stood near a check-out counter with her mother, Sharon, and sister, Chelsea.

During the confrontation, Walls slashed Ms. Meadows across her right arm and punctured a lung, which collapsed. She later recovered physically and is now attending college, but still suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder and continues to have pain in her arm.

Advertise with us

Ms. Meadows’ attorney, Lisa Circeo, told the jury of eight men and six women in her opening statement that the true blame for the incident falls on Target, which put “profits over protection.”

She contended that in the two years prior to the attack there were at least 17 reported crimes or incidents that occurred in the store ranging from assaults, to bomb threats, to an attempted child abduction.

Then, in May 2012, there was an incident that was “the straw that broke the camel’s back,” she said. A woman with a knife entered the store. No one was harmed. But the store manager decided to ask for armed security after that.

The store asked for Target Corp’s asset protection chief in Minneapolis, Joe Collins, to provide $87,000 to pay for armed police security all 105 hours a week the store was open. Mr. Collins offered to pay for 40 hours a week, at a cost of about $35,000, which the store used to provide an armed police officer from 4 p.m. to 11 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday, but not Sunday and Monday.

“They wouldn’t spend an extra $50,000 a year at this store to protect its customers,” Ms. Circeo told jurors.

Advertise with us

Mr. Birris, the Target attorney, said the armed security program was new at the time, and it was ”reasonable” for Target to start slower and not provide full-time security right away.

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill