The leadership of the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority was warned a year ago that the oversight agency’s books weren’t being reconciled regularly and that checks and balances on spending weren’t in place, according to an auditor’s letter received by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Monday.

Now the ICA’s records, seized last month by the Allegheny County district attorney, are potential evidence in a criminal probe. The job of clarifying the funds in the agency’s control, introducing more effective accounting and fixing relations with the mayor’s office now falls to interim executive director G. Reynolds “Renny” Clark, 73, of Squirrel Hill, who started this week.

“I think that we need to shore up our operations moving forward, and that’s probably the understatement of the day,” said B.J. Leber, the ICA board’s chair.

Ms. Leber authorized the release to the Post-Gazette of a letter, dated April 28, 2015, from auditors McGee Maruca & Associates to the ICA board. The firm had just completed its first audit of the ICA, which previously had another auditor.

Advertise with us

At the time, around $10 million in gambling revenue flowed annually through the state Treasury to the ICA, which would parcel it out to the city for debt reduction, pension funding and other fiscal improvements. The ICA was also getting $228,000 a year from the state for its operations, most of which went to pay Henry Sciortino, the longtime executive director.

Henry Sciortino

The auditors warned that "a complete bank reconciliation is not being performed on a monthly basis" and "strongly" recommended that such a reconciliation be performed monthly.

"The Executive Director is also the only check signer on the majority of disbursements," according to the letter, adding that while auditors did not find "irregularities," such an arrangement doesn't "allow for ample segregation of duties." Two people should sign all checks, the auditors wrote.

The letter went to the board at a time when it was led by attorney Nicholas Varischetti, who was not available Monday. Board member Michael Danovitz declined to comment, citing board policy to refer all questions to the chair. Ms. Leber was not a member of the board a year ago. Another former board member, Elise R. Yanders, could not be reached.

Advertise with us

Leslie A. McGee, one of the auditors, said her firm was not charged with reviewing every expenditure of the ICA, but rather looked at a sample of receipts. The auditors also checked the ICA’s records against information provided by the Treasury.

The ICA had not changed its one-signature policy by January, when Mr. Sciortino provided the city with a handwritten check for $2.9 million, signed only by him, according to Paul Leger, the city’s finance director. The city in March asked the ICA to issue monthly reports on its finances, competitively bid contracts above $10,000 and make other reforms.

The city has said that gambling revenue was wrongly withheld by the ICA, and has sued to compel its release. The ICA has made piecemeal releases, but Mr. Leger said that as of March, the balance of the funds due the city was $18.9 million.

"I certainly hope that we're going to get the money, and I think we will come to a reasonable resolution of that problem, but we have not pressed the board yet because they are reorganizing,” he said.

Ms. Leber said it’s too early to say whether the ICA will promptly settle the litigation and steer the balance to the city.

Advertise with us

City Controller Michael Lamb, though, predicted that under new ICA leadership, “if the city were to ask for release, there would be an additional release of funds to the city at this point.

“I do think that there will be a more conciliatory tone between the city and the ICA moving forward, given the new membership. And I'm hoping that at the next ICA meeting, there will be some move to discontinue the lawsuit, because that's done nothing but cost us money."

Mr. Clark is a former Westinghouse Electric executive and Franklin Park mayor, who was the University of Pittsburgh’s vice chancellor of external relations until June 2015.

He will be paid $75 an hour, for a 30-hour work week, or around $9,000 a month. The contract will run month to month. “I’m sure it’s going to be at least three to four months,” said Mr. Clark.

Mr. Sciortino is paid $12,000 a month. He will remain on the payroll through the end of this month, though he is no longer director. He could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Ms. Leber said the board had agreed to pay Mr. Sciortino for this month to comply with his contract.

“At this point in time, I need to find out how we can get functionality back to the office,” said Mr. Clark.

One of his first tasks will be to reach out to the agencies investigating the ICA, including the district attorney. That office last month cited in its search warrant the accounts of former ICA board member Ann M. Dugan, who told investigators that the oversight panel lacked organization and documentation.

Mr. Clark and Ms. Leber intend to go to Harrisburg to meet with the state agencies involved in the city’s recovery. The two would not rule out going beyond bookkeeping and becoming involved in discussions regarding the city’s fiscal structure.

“I am optimistic, and I don’t think it will take us long at all to get to the work that the ICA is really all about,” Ms. Leber said.

Advertise with us

"It's a much better day in the neighborhood than it has ever been before,” said Mr. Leger, “and we really look forward to a working relationship with this newly constituted board as opposed to opposition.”

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com. Kate Giammarise contributed.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.