Now it’s up to Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning to sort through conflicting details:
Did a 2014 Port Authority bus crash occur because two drivers were racing?
Or did one of the buses have a catastrophic mechanical failure that sent it off the side of Interstate 279?
Prosecutor Brian Catanzarite and attorneys for fired bus drivers Juliann Maier, 47, of Ross and Thomas Frauens, 57, of Brookline made their final arguments in the nonjury trial Tuesday. Judge Manning said he will issue his verdict on Thursday.
This much both sides agree on: Ms. Maier and Mr. Frauens left the Ross bus garage just after 2 p.m. Sept. 22, 2014, to begin their routes. A few minutes later, as they traveled side by side on I-279, Ms. Maier’s bus careened off the highway and landed on its side on Evergreen Road.
Beyond that the prosecutors painted this picture: Mr. Frauens, in the passing lane, gestured to Ms. Maier to race and while they were jockeying for position, the rear of her bus struck his. They say she over-corrected, sending the bus off the right side of the highway.
Mr. Frauens stopped several hundred yards down the highway and ran back to where Ms. Maier’s bus went over the hill, watched for a few minutes and left without reporting the incident.
Ms. Maier faces nine charges, including four misdemeanor counts of recklessly endangering another person and five summary counts including reckless and careless driving. Mr. Frauens faces 11 counts, including a felony charge of leaving the scene of an accident, five misdemeanors and five summary offenses.
The defense has a different version of events.
Attorney Joel Sansone, representing Ms. Maier, maintains that testimony from his client, other drivers and mechanical experts shows the bus had a major mechanical failure and she couldn’t control it.
Ms. Maier testified she never saw the gestures from her colleague because she was struggling to maintain control. The mechanical experts said the bus had at least four safety problems with the brakes and steering. Each would have caused it to fail a state inspection.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.