A Carrick woman will stand trial on charges that she stole at least $1 million worth of collectible stamps and other items from her employer in Squirrel Hill and sold them on eBay.

Colleen Carroll-Dean, 40, was held for trial on felony theft and other charges Tuesday by District Judge James Motznik at a preliminary hearing at City Court, Downtown.

Ms. Carroll-Dean was arrested in December when a search warrant was executed at her home and investigators found dozens of pages of colorful and valuable stamps, according to the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office.

Police said that Ms. Carroll-Dean swiped treasured sheets of stamps and other collectibles for months when she was one of four or five full- or part-time employees at Creative Products International in Squirrel Hill.

Advertise with us

Frances Todd Stewart, CEO of Creative Products International, said she received a call from a client who said that he had not received the Bhutan stamps that he had ordered from Ms. Carroll-Dean. That call came sometime after Ms. Carroll-Dean had stopped working for the company, Ms. Stewart said.

Ms. Stewart said she then discovered several boxes of stamps, as well as more taken from other boxes, were missing from the company’s inventory.

Ms. Stewart said that Ms. Carroll-Dean had been selling the stamps from her personal website, email and eBay accounts.

Colleen Carroll-Dean

Jackelyn Weibel, a detective with the district attorney’s office, testified that she found six to eight boxes of rare stamps when she was searching Ms. Carroll-Dean’s house.

Advertise with us

She said investigators also found a gallon plastic bag of marijuana as well as drug paraphernalia when searching the house. Authorities on Tuesday added drug possession, possession with intent to deliver and possession of drug paraphernalia charges against Ms. Carroll-Dean.

Randall McKinney, Ms. Carroll-Dean’s attorney, said that he respected the judge’s decision, but that the prosecution has more work ahead to prove Ms. Carroll-Dean is guilty at trial.

“I did find it interesting that there were multiple employees working there and the stamps were not in a secured facility,” he said. “I didn’t hear any testimony that there was an [Internet] address that could be connected to her.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.