When Malik Crosby was 2 years and 7 months old, his father was shot to death in a bar fight. But his mother never told him what happened, leaving the boy to wonder why his dad disappeared.

It wasn't until he was 8, forensic psychologist Alice Applegate testified Tuesday, that Malik learned the truth, from his grandfather.

“He was furious and believed his mother lied to him,” she said. Malik lost his trust in her and began acting out — leading to a string of placements in behavioral programs and psychiatric facilities — though no criminal charges.

That, combined with his chaotic childhood, a low IQ and a mental age of 6 to 8 years old, Ms. Applegate said, was among the reasons she recommended that his criminal case — for beating a boy to death at the former Circle C Youth and Family Services group home in Carrick — be heard in juvenile court.

Advertise with us

Malik, now 17, and Yusuf Shepard, 16, are charged with homicide and conspiracy in the beating of Nicholas Grant, 16, on Jan. 10, 2015. Nicholas died three days later. Defense attorneys for both teens have asked that their clients’ cases be moved to juvenile court. On Tuesday, Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning heard testimony in Malik’s case. He said he will rule at a later date.

Defense attorney Kelli Kleeb argued that her client was less culpable in the beating than his co-defendant, and that Malik didn’t participate until Nicholas threw a vacuum cleaner at him.

Ms. Applegate, who spent more than 4½ hours with Malik at the Allegheny County Jail conducting psychological testing and interviewing him, said the teen has waking flashbacks of Nicholas’ death and nightmares, and grieves for the victim.

Malik, who has aggression problems, is anxious and immature and very much in need of psychological services, she said. Still, she testified, he has a lower-than-average risk of committing other crimes and would be amenable to treatment in the juvenile justice system.

But Bruce Wright, a psychiatrist called by the prosecution, disagreed, noting that Malik had extensive treatment throughout his childhood, yet his problems persisted. He testified that Malik had a long history of violence and behavior problems and that he was unsure, during the 90 minutes he spent with Malik, that the teen told the truth.

Advertise with us

“Each account he provided, there was a different version,” Dr. Wright said. “You have to be forthright in order to be amenable [to treatment]. It’s my opinion the chance of effective treatment and rehabilitation during that period is minimal at best.“

In Pennsylvania, the juvenile court system has jurisdiction over offenders only until age 21, when they must be released.

Judge Manning questioned whether he could take a bifurcated approach to Malik’s case — sending the homicide charge to juvenile court but keeping the conspiracy charge in adult court, so that the term of supervision there could be extended for several years past Malik’s 21st birthday.

“I do not believe that has ever happened,” said prosecutor Melissa Byrnes, who argued Malik should stay in the adult system.

“It might be the wake-up call for the Legislature to know we’re not doing this properly,” Judge Manning said. “It doesn’t seem to me there’s any prohibition to it.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.