The Pittsburgh Parking Authority board voted today to sell a 125-space parking lot in East Liberty to the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, which is assembling parcels for a mixed-use development project, for $1 million, about a third of the value as determined by a “highest and best use” appraisal of the property.
“It’s Christmastime, so we might as well be charitable,” quipped board member Jeff Cohen.
The proposed Mellon’s Orchard South development, a residential, retail and office development, will also include up to 70 percent of rental units offered at below-market rate.
Twenty percent of the affordable units will at “rents that are affordable to income-producing households at or below 50 percent area median income,” with the rest “affordable to a range of household incomes between 30 percent and 120 percent of AMI.”
For 2015, area median income for a family of four was $69,700. The same family at 50 percent of area median income would earn $34,750.
Mr. Cohen said he would have liked to have seen more affordable housing for the parking authority’s money, given the rapid boom in development in the city’s East End and the potential for residents to be priced out of their neighborhood.
The board strayed from its policy of selling property for not less than its appraised value at the request of Mayor Bill Peduto's office.
“It’s critical that we do everything we can to increase affordable housing, particularly in East Liberty,” said Matt Barron, a parking authority board member and a former member of Mr. Peduto's administration.
Kyra Straussman, the URA’s director of real estate, said the highest and best use appraisal of $3.2 million for the lot, on North Beatty Street between Station and Ansley streets, reflects the potential for a high-end commercial development. Including affordable residential housing as a priority component lowered the value, she said.
David Onorato, the parking authority’s executive director, said at its peak the roughly one-acre lot generated about $9,000 a month but now produces less than half that.
The loss in revenue to the parking authority would be “minimal,” he said.
A request for proposals for the development has yet to go out and if the sale price for the land is higher than $1 million, the URA will "return some funds to you," Ms. Straussman told the parking authority board.
Kevin Acklin, chief of staff for the mayor and chairman of the URA board, said the $1 million appraisal is the only valid one, since it accurately reflects the city’s intention that the development include affordable housing. Purchasing the property for $3.2 million would have put the redevelopment authority “in a hole” and made the project less attractive to a developer willing to accomplish the city's goals, Mr. Acklin said.
Assembling the land for a market-rate development, Mr. Acklin said, would “further exacerbate the affordable-housing crisis” in the city and ignore "what the community is screaming for," he said.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.