James Eichenlaub called it a “declaration of war.”

But one thing remained unclear Tuesday after City Council passed two bills that impose hefty new fees for rental property owners and rules forbidding them from discriminating against housing voucher holders, commonly called Section 8 tenants. That’s whether the board of the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, which represents 30,000 units of rental housing in the city and where Mr. Eichenlaub serves as executive director, will return fire with legal action.

“In our opinion, they are overstepping the powers that are given to municipal governments,” Mr. Eichenlaub said.

A lawsuit defeated a similar rental registration program passed by council in 2007, with a much lower fee of $12 per unit. And though Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff, has said the program should stand up to legal scrutiny, Mr. Eichenlaub said the city’s math justifying the new schedule of fees, which start at $65 for owners of one to 10 units and drop to $45 for properties with more than 100 units, is deeply flawed. Mr. Acklin says the fee should pay for up to nine additional inspectors, but Mr. Eichenlaub says the city is also factoring in 3,000 hours a year of time by the director of the Departments of Permits, Licenses and Inspections.

Advertise with us

“It far exceeds the cost of regulating that particular unit,” Mr. Eichenlaub said, adding that he would present the final versions of the bills to his board.

Landlords have raised the possibility of another lawsuit to stop what they regard as the latest overreach this year of a City Council that also instituted new training requirements for security guards and other workers in large buildings and mandated paid sick leave for all city businesses, both of which are now being challenged in court on the basis that they exceed the city’s authority under the state’s Home Rule Charter law.

“Unfortunately, council in the past year has decided to test the court with the limit on how far they can go,” Mr. Eichenlaub said. “They have the ability to license and register landlords, but the fee has to be reasonable.”

Councilman Corey O’Connor and Darlene Harris voted against the rental registration program, both saying the fees are too high.

“If this was $10 or $15, I don’t think we’d get sued for that type of money,” Mrs. Harris said.

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Connor also said he has not “seen the change as much as we hoped” at the Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections, which would be in charge of enforcing the registry, since it was created out of the old Bureau of Building Inspection last year.

Mrs. Harris also voted against legislation by Councilman Ricky Burgess that would make “source of income,” including housing choice vouchers, a protected class, making it illegal for landlords to refuse tenants with the vouchers.

“I thought we live in America,” she said. “I don’t think we’re the ones who can tell them what they can and cannot do on private property.”

Mr. Burgess delivered a passionate defense of property rights in September in a debate on his bill that would require the owner’s consent before a city structure could get a historic designation and the protections against demolition it confers. He said his stance on housing voucher tenants wasn’t an inconsistent position.

“I don’t believe in discrimination,” he said. “The right to property is not absolute.”

Advertise with us

Helen Gerhardt, a member of the city's Commission on Human Relations, said about 41 percent of housing vouchers issued in the city are returned unused, in part because many landlords don't accept them. The commission endorsed the legislation and stands ready to enforce it, she said.

Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter:@rczullo.

Correction, posted Dec.16: A previous version of the article misinterpreted Helen Gerhardt’s statement on housing vouchers.