A shift to a self-insured medical plan will save Pittsburgh about $11 million next year with minimal changes for the roughly 3,700 city employees and retirees it will affect, Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration said Tuesday.
The change, which will have the city paying claims directly instead of premiums, also will ease the burden on employees as Pittsburgh comes into compliance with its recovery plan under the Act 47 program for distressed municipalities, the city said. That plan calls for workers to pay 20 percent of the total cost of their health care.
Changes for employees will be minor, said Sam Ashbaugh, director of the Office of Management and Budget. The city will retain its existing insurance providers, Highmark and HealthAmerica, and plans will remain unchanged, except for the increases in contributions over the next three years.
If the city had made the jump in contributions all at once next year, employees could have been paying an additional $168-$1,280 a year for health care, the mayor’s office said, depending on plan option and their “coverage tier.”
Under the phased-in approach, employee contributions are expected to go up by anywhere from $43 to $485 in 2016, an increase of 16.7 percent, depending on the coverage level. They will jump to 18.3 percent in 2017 before getting to 20 percent in 2018.
For 2015, the city will spend about $53 million to cover employees and retirees too young for Medicare. Barring any changes, that figure was expected to jump to $64 million in 2016, Mr. Ashbaugh said. Self-insuring will cut the cost to about $57 million.
Read More
A report prepared for the city by Towers Watson, a global employee benefits and human resources consulting firm, noted that “insurance companies under a fully-insured arrangement are in this business to make profit and will set premiums high / use conservative premium setting methods in order to meet their targets.”
“Setting the rates under a self-insured approach requires an unbiased look at historical costs and experience in order to best estimate future costs,” the report said, adding that it also involves the city assuming risk for paying claims. “If the actual claims, administrative costs, health-care reform fees and stop-loss premium is less than the projected budget, the city of Pittsburgh realizes that cost-avoidance. Alternatively if the actual costs exceed the projected budget, the city of Pittsburgh is responsible for the additional expense.”
Self-insuring also gives the city more incentive to enhance programs to reduce claims, such as coming improvements to the CityFit program, which gives employees $240 a year if they complete screenings and “wellness profiles,” designed to boost participation. Also, “wellness gurus” will work with employees to help improve their health and educate them on how to use computers and smartphones to access “telemedicine” care, which allows remote diagnosis of patients via video or phone, potentially avoiding an urgent care or emergency room visit.
The plan will include stop-loss coverage to guard against the risk of high-cost claims. According to the Towers Watson report, 52 high-cost claims, defined as those in excess of $50,000 each, cost insurers $6.1 million in 2012. There were 65 in 2013, costing $7.5 million and 69 in 2014, costing $6.1 million.
Mr. Ashbaugh said the changes must be approved by the unions that represent the vast majority of city employees.
“Each collective bargaining agreement is different and some have more flexibility than others,” Mr. Ashbaugh said. “Since employee contribution increases, even the smaller phased-in amounts proposed today need to be incorporated in the agreement we will work with the labor relations team to address based on where each unit is at in the bargaining process.”
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com, 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @rczullo.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.